"You oughtn't to yield to temptation. Well, somebody must, or the thing becomes absurd"
About this Quote
Temptation is usually framed as a test of character; Anthony Hope flips it into a problem of logistics. The line turns moral earnestness into farce by treating temptation like a social system that needs customers. If nobody yields, “the thing becomes absurd” not because virtue is bad, but because the whole melodrama of sin depends on someone playing the role. It’s a joke with teeth: morality isn’t just a private struggle, it’s also a public performance sustained by collective buy-in.
Hope writes in a late-Victorian/Edwardian moment when propriety was both strict and theatrical, with etiquette manuals on one side and scandal columns on the other. The subtext is that society likes temptation precisely because it can condemn it. A temptation without a fall provides no cautionary tale, no gossip, no proof that the rules are necessary. The line quietly accuses the moralist of needing sinners the way a preacher needs hell: as a foil, a fundraising tool, a source of narrative heat.
The wit works because it’s conversational and apparently reasonable. “Somebody must” mimics the tone of civic duty, smuggling in a cynical insight: our ethical ecosystems often outsource transgression so the rest can feel clean. It’s also a defense mechanism in miniature, the kind of quip a charming rake deploys to turn accountability into comedy. Hope isn’t endorsing vice so much as spotlighting how easily virtue becomes self-satisfied theater, and how society quietly depends on the very behavior it claims to despise.
Hope writes in a late-Victorian/Edwardian moment when propriety was both strict and theatrical, with etiquette manuals on one side and scandal columns on the other. The subtext is that society likes temptation precisely because it can condemn it. A temptation without a fall provides no cautionary tale, no gossip, no proof that the rules are necessary. The line quietly accuses the moralist of needing sinners the way a preacher needs hell: as a foil, a fundraising tool, a source of narrative heat.
The wit works because it’s conversational and apparently reasonable. “Somebody must” mimics the tone of civic duty, smuggling in a cynical insight: our ethical ecosystems often outsource transgression so the rest can feel clean. It’s also a defense mechanism in miniature, the kind of quip a charming rake deploys to turn accountability into comedy. Hope isn’t endorsing vice so much as spotlighting how easily virtue becomes self-satisfied theater, and how society quietly depends on the very behavior it claims to despise.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Anthony
Add to List






