"You should read history and look at ostracism, persecution, martyrdom, and that kind of thing. They always happen to the best men, you know"
About this Quote
A warning disguised as reassurance: if you find yourself shunned, it might not mean you were wrong. It might mean you were early, inconvenient, or simply too clear-eyed for the comfort of your moment. Eliot’s sentence works because it flips the usual moral accounting. Public punishment is often treated as proof of guilt; she treats it as evidence of quality, even virtue. The phrase “you should read history” isn’t homework advice. It’s a demand to step outside the claustrophobic logic of the present, where mobs feel like majorities and reputations can be crushed as if that settles an argument.
Her list moves with grim efficiency: ostracism (social erasure), persecution (institutional pressure), martyrdom (the final, sanctifying violence). By stacking them, she suggests a pipeline of cruelty that societies repeat with depressing consistency. The kicker is the offhand “you know,” a conversational shrug that makes the claim feel like common sense, as if the evidence is too obvious to dignify with drama. That casualness is part of the sting: history’s horrors aren’t aberrations; they’re patterns.
Context matters. Eliot lived as Mary Ann Evans, a woman who took a male pen name and entered a scandalous partnership with George Henry Lewes, enduring real social exclusion. She also wrote in a Victorian culture that prized moral respectability while regularly sacrificing dissidents, reformers, and “fallen” women to keep the facade intact. The subtext is personal and political: if society is condemning you, ask whether it’s defending goodness or defending itself.
Her list moves with grim efficiency: ostracism (social erasure), persecution (institutional pressure), martyrdom (the final, sanctifying violence). By stacking them, she suggests a pipeline of cruelty that societies repeat with depressing consistency. The kicker is the offhand “you know,” a conversational shrug that makes the claim feel like common sense, as if the evidence is too obvious to dignify with drama. That casualness is part of the sting: history’s horrors aren’t aberrations; they’re patterns.
Context matters. Eliot lived as Mary Ann Evans, a woman who took a male pen name and entered a scandalous partnership with George Henry Lewes, enduring real social exclusion. She also wrote in a Victorian culture that prized moral respectability while regularly sacrificing dissidents, reformers, and “fallen” women to keep the facade intact. The subtext is personal and political: if society is condemning you, ask whether it’s defending goodness or defending itself.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List














