"Young people should be helped, sheltered, ignored, and clubbed of necessary"
About this Quote
Al Capp, the acerbic creator of Li'l Abner, loved to compress paradox into a single hard jab. Here he stacks a set of incompatible commands for dealing with the young: help them, shelter them, ignore them, and, if it comes to it, crack down on them. The sequence moves from benevolence to withdrawal to outright force, mapping the emotional whiplash of adult attitudes toward youth. It sounds funny because it is brutally blunt and because each verb contradicts the last, but the humor hides a barbed observation: society lurches between sentimental protection, impatient dismissal, and punitive control without ever resolving what it actually wants from the next generation.
Capp delivered many of his sharpest lines during the cultural upheavals of the 1960s, when campus protests, the counterculture, and the civil rights movement unsettled older audiences. By then he had shifted from New Deal populism to a combative, often conservative stance. He toured colleges, baited student radicals, and made a point of puncturing what he saw as fashionable moralism. Against that backdrop, the escalation from help to shelter to indifference to the club reads like a caricature of the adult establishment’s playbook: first patronize, then overprotect, then tune out, and finally call in the cops. It also reflects Capp’s relish for provocation, daring listeners to ask whether they secretly endorse the last step when patience runs out.
Yet the line works as a mirror more than a program. It exposes the contradictory pressures placed on young people: be nurtured but tough, grateful but quiet, idealistic but compliant. It also challenges the older generation’s self-image, suggesting that what passes as wisdom is often oscillation and what passes as discipline may be frustration in disguise. The laughter it invites is uneasy, because it implicates everyone in the cycle. Under the swagger, the message is less a policy prescription than a diagnosis of chronic ambivalence, delivered with Capp’s trademark snap.
Capp delivered many of his sharpest lines during the cultural upheavals of the 1960s, when campus protests, the counterculture, and the civil rights movement unsettled older audiences. By then he had shifted from New Deal populism to a combative, often conservative stance. He toured colleges, baited student radicals, and made a point of puncturing what he saw as fashionable moralism. Against that backdrop, the escalation from help to shelter to indifference to the club reads like a caricature of the adult establishment’s playbook: first patronize, then overprotect, then tune out, and finally call in the cops. It also reflects Capp’s relish for provocation, daring listeners to ask whether they secretly endorse the last step when patience runs out.
Yet the line works as a mirror more than a program. It exposes the contradictory pressures placed on young people: be nurtured but tough, grateful but quiet, idealistic but compliant. It also challenges the older generation’s self-image, suggesting that what passes as wisdom is often oscillation and what passes as discipline may be frustration in disguise. The laughter it invites is uneasy, because it implicates everyone in the cycle. Under the swagger, the message is less a policy prescription than a diagnosis of chronic ambivalence, delivered with Capp’s trademark snap.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Al
Add to List
