"You're not free until you've been made captive by supreme belief"
About this Quote
Freedom, for Marianne Moore, is never the loose, braggy kind Americans like to sell themselves. It is disciplined, chosen, and a little paradoxical. "You're not free until you've been made captive by supreme belief" flips the usual script: captivity is not the enemy of liberty but its precondition. The provocation works because Moore treats belief not as a cozy opinion but as a binding force - something that arrests the wandering self and gives it a spine.
The line carries religious overtones ("supreme belief" brushes against faith), but Moore's intent is broader than doctrine. She is after a moral technology: the way a serious commitment can liberate you from smaller tyrannies. In Moore's world, the uncommitted person is not neutral; they are vulnerable - to fashion, to appetite, to social pressure, to whatever is loudest in the room. "Captive" names the discomfort of real conviction: it limits your options, costs you popularity, forces consistency. That narrowing is the point. Constraint becomes a kind of negative freedom, a protection against being yanked around by impulse and trend.
Context matters. Writing across modernism's churn - when inherited certainties were being questioned, politics and mass culture were growing more coercive, and "freedom" was becoming both slogan and commodity - Moore insists that liberation without allegiance is just drift. The subtext is almost a rebuke to the modern pose of ironic detachment. She suggests that the freest person isn't the one who can do anything, but the one who has finally found the thing they cannot betray.
The line carries religious overtones ("supreme belief" brushes against faith), but Moore's intent is broader than doctrine. She is after a moral technology: the way a serious commitment can liberate you from smaller tyrannies. In Moore's world, the uncommitted person is not neutral; they are vulnerable - to fashion, to appetite, to social pressure, to whatever is loudest in the room. "Captive" names the discomfort of real conviction: it limits your options, costs you popularity, forces consistency. That narrowing is the point. Constraint becomes a kind of negative freedom, a protection against being yanked around by impulse and trend.
Context matters. Writing across modernism's churn - when inherited certainties were being questioned, politics and mass culture were growing more coercive, and "freedom" was becoming both slogan and commodity - Moore insists that liberation without allegiance is just drift. The subtext is almost a rebuke to the modern pose of ironic detachment. She suggests that the freest person isn't the one who can do anything, but the one who has finally found the thing they cannot betray.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Marianne
Add to List
