"You've got to be a thermostat rather than a thermometer. A thermostat shapes the climate of opinion; a thermometer just reflects it"
About this Quote
West’s metaphor lands because it flatters and indicts at the same time. Nobody wants to be “just” a thermometer, passively reporting the temperature of a room already decided by louder voices, market incentives, or tribal loyalties. The thermostat, by contrast, implies agency with a moral charge: you don’t merely notice the chill of cynicism or the fever of outrage; you set a different temperature and hold it there.
The intent is unapologetically pedagogical. As an educator and public intellectual, West is arguing that thinking is not a spectator sport. The subtext: neutrality is rarely neutral. In a culture that rewards hot takes and reactive commentary, the “thermometer” becomes a stand-in for punditry that treats public sentiment as fate, or for institutions (including universities) that confuse describing injustice with confronting it.
Context matters because “climate of opinion” hints at more than mood; it’s about power. Thermometers are useful, even necessary, but they can be weaponized as alibis: “I’m just telling you how people feel,” “I’m just reading the polls,” “I’m just following the data.” West’s line pushes back against that technocratic refuge. Shaping opinion means risking unpopularity, refusing the seductions of consensus, and being willing to absorb backlash for setting the dial toward justice.
It works rhetorically because it’s simple, repeatable, and operational. You can picture the two devices instantly, and the choice is binary enough to function like a dare: Are you reporting the room, or changing it?
The intent is unapologetically pedagogical. As an educator and public intellectual, West is arguing that thinking is not a spectator sport. The subtext: neutrality is rarely neutral. In a culture that rewards hot takes and reactive commentary, the “thermometer” becomes a stand-in for punditry that treats public sentiment as fate, or for institutions (including universities) that confuse describing injustice with confronting it.
Context matters because “climate of opinion” hints at more than mood; it’s about power. Thermometers are useful, even necessary, but they can be weaponized as alibis: “I’m just telling you how people feel,” “I’m just reading the polls,” “I’m just following the data.” West’s line pushes back against that technocratic refuge. Shaping opinion means risking unpopularity, refusing the seductions of consensus, and being willing to absorb backlash for setting the dial toward justice.
It works rhetorically because it’s simple, repeatable, and operational. You can picture the two devices instantly, and the choice is binary enough to function like a dare: Are you reporting the room, or changing it?
Quote Details
| Topic | Leadership |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Cornel
Add to List










