Job: A Comedy of Justice
Premise
Heinlein follows Alex Hergensheimer and his companion Margrethe on a bewildering, satirical odyssey that mirrors the Biblical Book of Job. What begins as a road-trip romance soon fractures into a sequence of reality shifts that force the couple to confront divine caprice, cosmic bureaucracy, and the problem of undeserved suffering. The central conceit treats theology and metaphysics as movable scenery: gods, devils, and entire religious worlds are real and interchangeable across alternate universes.
Narrative arc
Alex and Margrethe are ordinary people whose lives are repeatedly upended by events that resemble apocalyptic reckonings and miraculous reversals. As they slip from one universe to another, each world obeys different theological rules and moral economies. The pair experience rapture-like separations, miraculous restorations, and legalistic reckonings administered by divine beings and their agents. The episodic travel between realities becomes a framework for a sustained interrogation of justice: why do good people suffer, and what, if any, moral logic underlies a cosmos that can be reshaped by gods?
Themes and tone
A wry blend of satire, earnest moral inquiry, and road-novel momentum gives the book an unusual tonal mix that ranges from black humor to philosophical seriousness. Heinlein interrogates faith, free will, and the relationship between individual conscience and supernatural authority. Comedy arises from the absurdities of divine administration and from the collision between pragmatic human ethics and metaphysical justifications for suffering. Underneath the satire, a persistent question remains: can a human being maintain integrity and compassion when the cosmos seems indifferent or capricious?
Characters and voice
Alex functions as everyman and moral inquirer, pragmatic yet searching for meaning; Margrethe supplies emotional ballast, loyalty, and a human face to the consequences of metaphysical games. Secondary figures, angels, demons, clerical functionaries, are sketched with a mix of caricature and unsettling verisimilitude that undercuts received religious images. Heinlein's voice is colloquial, often conversational, and occasionally provocative, using plainspoken dialogue and pointed debates to stage theological and ethical dilemmas.
Philosophical stakes
The novel treats divine justice as an ethical puzzle rather than settled dogma. Questions about punishment, reward, and the purpose of suffering are dramatized rather than sermonized, forcing characters to make moral choices without easy assurances. Issues of personal responsibility, loyalty, and the limits of religious certainty are foregrounded: faith is tested by absurdity and loss, and redemption often looks far more complicated than doctrinal promises suggest.
Legacy and impact
Controversial on release for its irreverent treatment of sacred themes, the novel has since been recognized as a distinctive late-career work that blends Heinlein's skeptical streak with a genuine grappling with spiritual questions. It reads as both a theological thought-experiment and a human story about love and endurance. Readers who enjoy speculative premises used to illuminate moral dilemmas will find the book provocative, unsettling, and often darkly funny.
Heinlein follows Alex Hergensheimer and his companion Margrethe on a bewildering, satirical odyssey that mirrors the Biblical Book of Job. What begins as a road-trip romance soon fractures into a sequence of reality shifts that force the couple to confront divine caprice, cosmic bureaucracy, and the problem of undeserved suffering. The central conceit treats theology and metaphysics as movable scenery: gods, devils, and entire religious worlds are real and interchangeable across alternate universes.
Narrative arc
Alex and Margrethe are ordinary people whose lives are repeatedly upended by events that resemble apocalyptic reckonings and miraculous reversals. As they slip from one universe to another, each world obeys different theological rules and moral economies. The pair experience rapture-like separations, miraculous restorations, and legalistic reckonings administered by divine beings and their agents. The episodic travel between realities becomes a framework for a sustained interrogation of justice: why do good people suffer, and what, if any, moral logic underlies a cosmos that can be reshaped by gods?
Themes and tone
A wry blend of satire, earnest moral inquiry, and road-novel momentum gives the book an unusual tonal mix that ranges from black humor to philosophical seriousness. Heinlein interrogates faith, free will, and the relationship between individual conscience and supernatural authority. Comedy arises from the absurdities of divine administration and from the collision between pragmatic human ethics and metaphysical justifications for suffering. Underneath the satire, a persistent question remains: can a human being maintain integrity and compassion when the cosmos seems indifferent or capricious?
Characters and voice
Alex functions as everyman and moral inquirer, pragmatic yet searching for meaning; Margrethe supplies emotional ballast, loyalty, and a human face to the consequences of metaphysical games. Secondary figures, angels, demons, clerical functionaries, are sketched with a mix of caricature and unsettling verisimilitude that undercuts received religious images. Heinlein's voice is colloquial, often conversational, and occasionally provocative, using plainspoken dialogue and pointed debates to stage theological and ethical dilemmas.
Philosophical stakes
The novel treats divine justice as an ethical puzzle rather than settled dogma. Questions about punishment, reward, and the purpose of suffering are dramatized rather than sermonized, forcing characters to make moral choices without easy assurances. Issues of personal responsibility, loyalty, and the limits of religious certainty are foregrounded: faith is tested by absurdity and loss, and redemption often looks far more complicated than doctrinal promises suggest.
Legacy and impact
Controversial on release for its irreverent treatment of sacred themes, the novel has since been recognized as a distinctive late-career work that blends Heinlein's skeptical streak with a genuine grappling with spiritual questions. It reads as both a theological thought-experiment and a human story about love and endurance. Readers who enjoy speculative premises used to illuminate moral dilemmas will find the book provocative, unsettling, and often darkly funny.
Job: A Comedy of Justice
A satirical, theologically tinged novel following Alex Hergensheimer as he is swept through alternate worlds and religious scenarios while attempting to return to his love.
- Publication Year: 1984
- Type: Novel
- Genre: Science Fiction, Satire
- Language: en
- Characters: Alex Hergensheimer
- View all works by Robert A. Heinlein on Amazon
Author: Robert A. Heinlein

More about Robert A. Heinlein
- Occup.: Writer
- From: USA
- Other works:
- Life-Line (1939 Short Story)
- The Man Who Sold the Moon (1940 Short Story)
- The Roads Must Roll (1940 Short Story)
- Methuselah's Children (1941 Novel)
- Beyond This Horizon (1942 Novel)
- Waldo (1942 Short Story)
- The Puppet Masters (1951 Novel)
- Double Star (1956 Novel)
- The Door into Summer (1957 Novel)
- Citizen of the Galaxy (1957 Novel)
- Have Space Suit, Will Travel (1958 Children's book)
- All You Zombies— (1959 Short Story)
- Starship Troopers (1959 Novel)
- Stranger in a Strange Land (1961 Novel)
- Glory Road (1963 Novel)
- The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress (1966 Novel)
- I Will Fear No Evil (1970 Novel)
- Time Enough for Love (1973 Novel)
- The Cat Who Walks Through Walls (1985 Novel)