Book: Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity

Overview and Context
Richard Hooker’s Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity is a large-scale theological, legal, and political defense of the Elizabethan Church of England against Puritan calls for Genevan-style presbyterian reform. Written amid the late sixteenth-century controversies that followed the English Reformation, it seeks to justify episcopal governance, set liturgies, and royal oversight of church affairs as lawful, reasonable, and conducive to the common good. Hooker published the first four books in 1593, added Book V in 1597, and the remaining books appeared posthumously. His approach blends scriptural exegesis with classical philosophy and the common-law habit of reasoning from precedent and prudence.

Law and the Ordering of Creation
The treatise begins by enlarging the concept of law. Drawing on Aristotle and Aquinas, Hooker describes a hierarchy of laws: the eternal law by which God governs all things; natural law, accessible to human reason; divine law revealed in Scripture; and human positive laws, which prudently apply higher norms to particular circumstances. Human communities must order themselves by laws that aim at the good of the whole, and such laws may vary with time and place. This framework allows Hooker to argue that church polity is not a single, immutable scheme mandated for all ages, but a practical application of enduring principles to contingent settings.

Scripture, Reason, and Custom
Hooker affirms Scripture’s sufficiency in matters necessary to salvation, yet denies that every feature of ecclesiastical life requires an explicit biblical command. Where Scripture does not prescribe or proscribe, reason and the long usage of the church may guide. He treats many disputed practices, vestments, set forms of prayer, kneeling at communion, as things indifferent, or adiaphora, whose lawfulness depends on whether they edify, preserve order, and do not obscure the gospel. In resisting a rigorist principle that only what Scripture expressly commands is permitted, Hooker safeguards Christian liberty and the church’s capacity to legislate prudently.

Church, Commonwealth, and Authority
Hooker depicts England as a Christian commonwealth, one society under God in which the same people are citizens and church members. The civil magistrate, as the realm’s supreme governor, possesses authority over the church’s external governance, provided this authority is exercised for the community’s good and never against the substance of the faith. This is not a surrender of the church to the state but a vision of harmonized jurisdictions within a single body politic. Authority in the church is ministerial rather than absolute, ordered toward peace, truth, and the salvation of souls, and always accountable to God’s higher law.

Liturgy and Episcopacy
Against Puritan attacks on the Book of Common Prayer and episcopal order, Hooker defends ceremonial and hierarchical forms as ancient, fitting, and pastorally wise. Liturgy disciplines affection and unites the community in public worship; episcopacy preserves unity, continuity, and effective oversight. He does not claim that bishops are divinely required in every age by unalterable law, but that they are lawful, deeply rooted in apostolic practice, and superior to proposed alternatives in promoting the church’s ends. Change in rites or governance is neither inherently good nor bad; reforms should proceed by measured judgment, not zeal or novelty.

Style, Method, and Legacy
Marked by patience, charity, and exacting argument, the work models a via media that rejects both authoritarian imposition and radical purism. Hooker’s synthesis of Scripture, reason, and tradition became emblematic of Anglican theology, even as he resists reducing the church’s discernment to any single rule. His account of law and prudence influenced later English political thought and provided a durable framework for negotiating continuity and change in ecclesial life. The Laws remains a touchstone for debates about authority, conscience, and the public shape of Christian worship.

Cite this Page