Novel: Troubling a Star
Overview
Troubling a Star follows teenage Polly O'Keefe as she is swept from a comfortable life into a perilous international mystery that tests her courage, wits, and loyalties. The novel moves quickly from a family holiday into a cross-border chase whose stakes are at once political and deeply personal. Madeleine L'Engle blends suspense with reflective moments that probe identity, responsibility, and the costs of truth.
Main Plot
While traveling abroad, Polly becomes the target of a violent abduction attempt that forces her to flee and survive on her own. The immediate danger leads her into a wider web of intrigue involving shadowy figures, international politics, and scientific interests that have implications beyond any single country. As she evades capture and seeks the reasons behind the attack, Polly uncovers secrets that connect to people she loves and to broader ethical questions about power and knowledge.
Polly's Journey
The narrative is as much about inner growth as it is about outward escape. Polly's flight requires quick thinking, resourcefulness, and an ability to trust strangers when necessary. Confronted with fear and isolation, she discovers reserves of resilience and moral clarity, learning to make difficult choices under pressure. Her journey forces her to balance independence with dependence on others, negotiating alliances that are sometimes temporary and sometimes life-saving.
Characters
Polly is at the center: perceptive, brave, and still forming her sense of self. Her family looms in the background as a source of love and worry, and a number of adult figures, scientists, officials, and fellow travelers, shape the course of events, offering help, obfuscation, or outright danger. Antagonists operate through deception and force, and their motives intertwine ideological, political, and economic interests. The supporting cast highlights contrasts among integrity, ambition, and desperation.
Themes
The novel explores coming-of-age under extreme circumstances, examining how crisis accelerates maturation and clarifies values. Questions of trust and betrayal recur: whom to believe, when to reveal the truth, and how much to risk for justice. There is also a sustained concern with moral responsibility toward scientific and political knowledge, and with how personal loyalties intersect with public consequences. Family and friendship act as anchors, even when everything else feels uncertain.
Tone and Style
L'Engle's prose mixes brisk, suspenseful scenes with contemplative, character-driven moments. The pacing alternates between taut sequences of pursuit and quieter reflections that deepen emotional resonance. Dialogue and internal monologue reveal Polly's intelligence and compassion, while descriptive passages situate the reader in varied settings that emphasize both beauty and peril. The overall tone balances youthful determination with thoughtful seriousness.
Conclusion
Troubling a Star closes with resolution that restores safety while acknowledging the lasting impact of trauma and discovery. Polly emerges with a stronger sense of who she is and what she values, having confronted danger and deception and having chosen a path informed by courage and empathy. The novel leaves readers with a depiction of adolescence shaped by adventure, moral choice, and the steady pull of family ties.
Troubling a Star follows teenage Polly O'Keefe as she is swept from a comfortable life into a perilous international mystery that tests her courage, wits, and loyalties. The novel moves quickly from a family holiday into a cross-border chase whose stakes are at once political and deeply personal. Madeleine L'Engle blends suspense with reflective moments that probe identity, responsibility, and the costs of truth.
Main Plot
While traveling abroad, Polly becomes the target of a violent abduction attempt that forces her to flee and survive on her own. The immediate danger leads her into a wider web of intrigue involving shadowy figures, international politics, and scientific interests that have implications beyond any single country. As she evades capture and seeks the reasons behind the attack, Polly uncovers secrets that connect to people she loves and to broader ethical questions about power and knowledge.
Polly's Journey
The narrative is as much about inner growth as it is about outward escape. Polly's flight requires quick thinking, resourcefulness, and an ability to trust strangers when necessary. Confronted with fear and isolation, she discovers reserves of resilience and moral clarity, learning to make difficult choices under pressure. Her journey forces her to balance independence with dependence on others, negotiating alliances that are sometimes temporary and sometimes life-saving.
Characters
Polly is at the center: perceptive, brave, and still forming her sense of self. Her family looms in the background as a source of love and worry, and a number of adult figures, scientists, officials, and fellow travelers, shape the course of events, offering help, obfuscation, or outright danger. Antagonists operate through deception and force, and their motives intertwine ideological, political, and economic interests. The supporting cast highlights contrasts among integrity, ambition, and desperation.
Themes
The novel explores coming-of-age under extreme circumstances, examining how crisis accelerates maturation and clarifies values. Questions of trust and betrayal recur: whom to believe, when to reveal the truth, and how much to risk for justice. There is also a sustained concern with moral responsibility toward scientific and political knowledge, and with how personal loyalties intersect with public consequences. Family and friendship act as anchors, even when everything else feels uncertain.
Tone and Style
L'Engle's prose mixes brisk, suspenseful scenes with contemplative, character-driven moments. The pacing alternates between taut sequences of pursuit and quieter reflections that deepen emotional resonance. Dialogue and internal monologue reveal Polly's intelligence and compassion, while descriptive passages situate the reader in varied settings that emphasize both beauty and peril. The overall tone balances youthful determination with thoughtful seriousness.
Conclusion
Troubling a Star closes with resolution that restores safety while acknowledging the lasting impact of trauma and discovery. Polly emerges with a stronger sense of who she is and what she values, having confronted danger and deception and having chosen a path informed by courage and empathy. The novel leaves readers with a depiction of adolescence shaped by adventure, moral choice, and the steady pull of family ties.
Troubling a Star
A later young?adult novel following Polly O'Keefe on an international adventure involving mystery, political intrigue and personal growth as she confronts danger while searching for family and truth.
- Publication Year: 1994
- Type: Novel
- Genre: Young Adult, Adventure, Mystery
- Language: en
- Characters: Polly O'Keefe
- View all works by Madeleine L'Engle on Amazon
Author: Madeleine L'Engle

More about Madeleine L'Engle
- Occup.: Novelist
- From: USA
- Other works:
- And Both Were Young (1949 Novel)
- Camilla Dickinson (1951 Novel)
- Meet the Austins (1960 Novel)
- A Wrinkle in Time (1962 Novel)
- The Moon by Night (1963 Novel)
- The Arm of the Starfish (1965 Novel)
- A Circle of Quiet (1972 Memoir)
- A Wind in the Door (1973 Novel)
- The Irrational Season (1977 Essay)
- A Swiftly Tilting Planet (1978 Novel)
- A Ring of Endless Light (1980 Novel)
- A House Like a Lotus (1984 Novel)
- Many Waters (1986 Novel)
- Two‑Part Invention: The Story of a Marriage (1988 Autobiography)
- An Acceptable Time (1989 Novel)
- Walking on Water: Reflections on Faith and Art (2001 Non-fiction)