And One Was Beautiful (1940)

And One Was Beautiful Poster

A teenager falls hard for an irresponsible playboy.

Film Overview
"And One was Beautiful" is a 1940 American drama movie directed by Robert B. Sinclair. The movie was based upon the 1937 novel "And One was Beautiful" by Alice Duer Miller. It stars Robert Cummings, Laraine Day, and Jean Muir and shows an engaging narrative about deceit, love, household and redemption. The drama focuses on the lives of 2 sis, the choices they make, and the unexpected consequences of their actions.

Plot Summary
The story follows the elaborate lives of two siblings, Helen (Jean Muir) and Katherine Lattimer (Laraine Day), who originate from a rich family. Older sis Helen is sorry and tends to make ethically best options, while Katherine, the free-spirited more youthful sis, enjoys living on the edge. Katherine's recklessness ultimately leads her to a series of regrettable occasions.

The plotline thickens with the introduction of Ridley Crane (Robert Cummings), a garage mechanic. Both sisters fall for Ridley, however Ridley's heart leans towards Helen. Helen at first turns down Ridley due to their social distinctions, and he quickly finds solace in Katherine's arms. After a night of negligent driving leading to a hit and run incident, Ridley reluctantly helps Katherine in concealing the reality to protect her. Nevertheless, their attempts to bury their criminal offense backfires as they face unforeseen outcomes.

Character Development and Plot Progression
As the story unfolds, the characters' transformations are substantial. Helen grows and establishes strong sensations for Ridley, and she makes attempts to heal her relationship with her sibling. On the other hand, Katherine, at first flirtatious and charismatic, becomes deeply entangled in regret and fear after the accident.

Ridley is mistakenly founded guilty for the hit and run mishap, and Katherine reveals no signs of confessing the truth. Helen takes matters into her hands to save Ridley, later showing his innocence. The truth's revelation leads to Katherine receiving a just sentence, while Helen and Ridley revive their love. The plotline masterfully displays the negative impacts of pride, vanity, and deceit.

Conclusion and Impact
"And One was Beautiful" showcases a detailed ethical lesson on honesty, love, and redemption, driven by the dynamics in between the Lattimer siblings and Ridley. Katherine, who was as soon as breathtakingly beautiful and negligent, ends up losing her appeal and flexibility due to her pride and deceit. On the other hand, Helen, who was at first unwilling to welcome her sensations, takes a stand to reveal the reality, eventually causing Ridley's liberty and restoring her lost love.

Moreover, through Ridley's character, the film highlights the unfair social norms where an innocent gets punished due to lack of social status and the corrupt who get away due to their abundance. Ridley's character gets substantial gratitude for staying ethically grounded regardless of being mistakenly implicated and dealing with hardships.

In conclusion, Robert B. Sinclair utilizes "And One was Beautiful" to show the idea that the real charm of an individual depends on their morals, sincerity, and character instead of their physical appearance. This message is strongly portrayed through the change of the two siblings, making this film a memorable classic from 1940.

Top Cast

  • Robert Cummings (small)
    Robert Cummings
    Ridley Crane
  • Laraine Day (small)
    Laraine Day
    Kate Lattimer
  • Jean Muir (small)
    Jean Muir
    Helen Lattimer
  • Billie Burke (small)
    Billie Burke
    Julia Lattimer
  • Ann Morriss (small)
    Ann Morriss
    Gertrude Hunter
  • Esther Dale (small)
    Esther Dale
    Margaret
  • Charles Waldron (small)
    Charles Waldron
    Stephen Harridge
  • Rand Brooks (small)
    Rand Brooks
    Joe Havens
  • Ruth Tobey (small)
    Ruth Tobey
    Zillah
  • Frank Milan
    George Olcott
  • Paul Stanton (small)
    Paul Stanton
    Arthur Prince