When a Man Loves (1927)

When a Man Loves Poster

A nobleman studying for the priesthood abandons his vocation in 18th Century France when he falls in love with a beautiful, but reluctant, courtesan.

Introduction
"When a Man Loves" is a silent romantic drama movie from 1927, directed by Alan Crosland. The movie, distributed by Warner Bros., stars John Barrymore and Dolores Costello. It's motivated by The Man Who Laughs, an unique written by Victor Hugo. As a landmark in the quiet movie period, it exemplifies the design and style of melodrama, characterized by extreme feeling and exaggerated character portrayals.

Plot Overview
The movie focuses on the significant romance of Chevalier Fabien des Grieux (John Barrymore) and Manon Lescaut (Dolores Costello). The plot unfolds during the reign of Louis XV when des Grieux saves Manon from being powerfully sent out to reside in a convent by rescuing her from a detaining officer. The two elope and discover themselves growing progressively in love.

Disputes and Development
Their love, nevertheless, is short-lived as Manon's brother, André (Warner Oland), persuades her to leave des Grieux for an older but wealthy gentleman, de Brétigny(Warner Oland). Caught up in an issue, Manon considers her decision, constrained by the social pressures of financial stability and real love.

Des Grieux, upon knowing of Manon's intended departure, is heartbroken but develops a double strategy. He first works together with André to win a card video game versus de Brétigny, hoping to secure a monetary future for Manon and himself. Simultaneously, he plans to kidnap Manon thinking this strong action will prevent her from leaving him.

Resolution and Conclusion
His strategies go awry when both he and André are unmasked, resulting in a foil to des Grieux's intentions. The amorous couple are exiled to America by an exasperated de Brétigny. In a tragic shipwreck en route to the New World, André dies while Manon, des Grieux, and another survivor are required to cannibalize him. The traumatic experience creates an extensive realization in Manon, and she reconciles with des Grieux.

The couple discovers themselves marooned in an unoccupied land after the shipwreck, however the difficulties they sustain strengthen their love for each other. The film ends on a hopeful note when they are found by a rescue ship, and their deep bond is sealed throughout their trials and adversities.

Vital Analysis
"When a Man Loves" showcases John Barrymore's flexibility as a star, and Dolores Costello complements his efficiency with her compelling representation of Manon. The movie is notable for its profound character development and the potent styles it brings into play, such as love, sacrifice and enduring hardships.

Overall, "When a Man Loves" is a turning point in film history, including the exceptional artistry of the quiet film period with its emphasis on visual story and the exploration of relatable sociological problems. It efficiently depicts Victor Hugo's narrative, changing it into a romantic legendary making it a memorable movie from the period before talkies.

Top Cast

  • John Barrymore (small)
    John Barrymore
    Chevalier Fabien des Grieux
  • Dolores Costello (small)
    Dolores Costello
    Manon Lescaut
  • Warner Oland (small)
    Warner Oland
    André Lescaut
  • Sam De Grasse (small)
    Sam De Grasse
    Comte Guillot de Morfontaine
  • Holmes Herbert (small)
    Holmes Herbert
    Jean Tiberge
  • Stuart Holmes (small)
    Stuart Holmes
    Louis XV - King of France
  • Bertram Grassby (small)
    Bertram Grassby
    Le Duc de Richelieu
  • Tom Santschi (small)
    Tom Santschi
    Captain of Convict Boat
  • Alice Belcher
    Minor Role (uncredited)
  • Eugenie Besserer (small)
    Eugenie Besserer
    The Landlady (uncredited)
  • Charles Clary (small)
    Charles Clary
    A Lay Brother (uncredited)