"A feeble execution is but another phrase for a bad execution; and a government ill executed, whatever may be its theory, must, in practice, be a bad government"
About this Quote
Story’s line lands like a judge’s gavel on the softest alibi in politics: “good ideas” are not a defense. By collapsing “feeble” into “bad,” he strips away the comforting middle category leaders love to hide in - the claim that they meant well, or that the blueprint is sound even if the build is shaky. In his framing, competence isn’t a bonus feature of governance; it is the governing. Theory that can’t survive contact with administration, enforcement, budgets, and human incentives is, functionally, just theory.
The subtext is a warning to a young republic intoxicated by constitutional design. Story, a Supreme Court justice in an era of fierce argument over federal power, is implicitly siding with the institutionalist view: legitimacy comes from reliable outcomes, not abstract purity. A constitution can promise rights, markets, and representation, but if courts can’t adjudicate, agencies can’t implement, and officials can’t execute without corruption or paralysis, the “good government” becomes a paper performance. He’s also preempting a common rhetorical trick: blaming failure on sabotage or circumstance while insisting the ideology remains immaculate.
Context matters: early 19th-century America was still stress-testing federal authority, banking, internal improvements, and the very machinery of law across a sprawling nation. Story’s realism reads like an argument for capacity - professional administration, coherent legal standards, and a government strong enough to do the unglamorous work. The sharpness is deliberate: execution is where political morality meets reality, and reality is the final court.
The subtext is a warning to a young republic intoxicated by constitutional design. Story, a Supreme Court justice in an era of fierce argument over federal power, is implicitly siding with the institutionalist view: legitimacy comes from reliable outcomes, not abstract purity. A constitution can promise rights, markets, and representation, but if courts can’t adjudicate, agencies can’t implement, and officials can’t execute without corruption or paralysis, the “good government” becomes a paper performance. He’s also preempting a common rhetorical trick: blaming failure on sabotage or circumstance while insisting the ideology remains immaculate.
Context matters: early 19th-century America was still stress-testing federal authority, banking, internal improvements, and the very machinery of law across a sprawling nation. Story’s realism reads like an argument for capacity - professional administration, coherent legal standards, and a government strong enough to do the unglamorous work. The sharpness is deliberate: execution is where political morality meets reality, and reality is the final court.
Quote Details
| Topic | Management |
|---|
More Quotes by Joseph
Add to List
