"A reasonable doubt is nothing more than a doubt for which reasons can be given. The fact that 1 or 2 men out of 12 differ from the others does not establish that their doubts are reasonable"
- Lord Hailsham
About this Quote
This quote by Lord Hailsham is describing the concept of affordable uncertainty in a legal context. Practical uncertainty is a lawful standard that should be fulfilled in order for a jury to found guilty a defendant of a criminal offense. It is a greater requirement than a prevalence of the evidence, which is the typical used in civil cases. Lord Hailsham is saying that a reasonable doubt is not simply any kind of uncertainty, however one that can be sustained by reasons. He is also saying that the reality that one or two jurors out of twelve differ with the others does not necessarily mean that their uncertainties are practical. This quote highlights the significance of having an affordable question in order to convict an accused of a crime. It also highlights the value of having a court of twelve individuals, as it enables a selection of viewpoints and perspectives to be considered.
About the Author