"A self-made man may prefer a self-made name"
About this Quote
Hand’s line slices through a foundational American romance: the “self-made man” myth. He takes the stock phrase and gives it a legalist’s twist, reminding you that identity isn’t just earned through work; it can be engineered through language. “May prefer” is doing quiet, judicial work here. It’s not a sermon about vanity, it’s an observation about incentives. If you’ve built yourself from scratch, why wouldn’t you want the label to match the labor?
The subtext is about control. Names are shorthand for status, lineage, belonging. A “self-made” person, by definition, lacks the inherited brand advantages of old families, old money, old networks. Choosing a “self-made name” becomes a way to sever ties to origins that feel limiting or stigmatized, and to draft a résumé in a single word: crisper, more pronounceable, more “American,” more marketable. It’s aspiration with paperwork.
Hand, a judge steeped in the machinery of official identity (signatures, records, titles, precedent), also hints at how malleable the supposedly fixed self can be. Courts care about names because names anchor rights and responsibilities; culture cares because names anchor perception. The wit is that self-making doesn’t stop at character or fortune. It extends to the branding layer we pretend is incidental.
Read in its early-20th-century context, it nods to immigrant Anglicization, professional reinvention, and the social climbing that modern capitalism both enables and demands. Hand’s dry formulation leaves room for sympathy and suspicion: reinvention as freedom, and reinvention as performance. Either way, he understands the quiet power of the label.
The subtext is about control. Names are shorthand for status, lineage, belonging. A “self-made” person, by definition, lacks the inherited brand advantages of old families, old money, old networks. Choosing a “self-made name” becomes a way to sever ties to origins that feel limiting or stigmatized, and to draft a résumé in a single word: crisper, more pronounceable, more “American,” more marketable. It’s aspiration with paperwork.
Hand, a judge steeped in the machinery of official identity (signatures, records, titles, precedent), also hints at how malleable the supposedly fixed self can be. Courts care about names because names anchor rights and responsibilities; culture cares because names anchor perception. The wit is that self-making doesn’t stop at character or fortune. It extends to the branding layer we pretend is incidental.
Read in its early-20th-century context, it nods to immigrant Anglicization, professional reinvention, and the social climbing that modern capitalism both enables and demands. Hand’s dry formulation leaves room for sympathy and suspicion: reinvention as freedom, and reinvention as performance. Either way, he understands the quiet power of the label.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Learned
Add to List
