"All greatness of character is dependent on individuality. The man who has no other existence than that which he partakes in common with all around him, will never have any other than an existence of mediocrity"
About this Quote
Greatness, Cooper insists, is not a moral trophy you win by behaving correctly; it is a byproduct of being unmistakably yourself. The jab is aimed at the social type who lives entirely by consensus, borrowing identity from the crowd the way one borrows fashion: safe, legible, and therefore spiritually small. By tying "greatness of character" to "individuality", he rejects the comforting idea that virtue is just compliance with a shared code. For Cooper, character emerges when a person has an inner spine strong enough to resist the easy gravity of the common.
The subtext is a distinctly American anxiety and ambition. Writing in the early republic, Cooper watched a nation invent itself while also flattening people into respectable sameness: churchgoing propriety, civic pieties, the pressure to be "one of us". His frontier fiction romanticized figures who stand apart from settled society, and this line reads like the moral thesis behind that aesthetic. Individuality becomes a kind of ethical courage, not mere quirkiness: the willingness to risk misunderstanding, ridicule, even exile from the communal story.
His rhetoric is bluntly binary, almost Puritan in its consequence. "No other existence" versus "greatness"; "common" versus "mediocrity". That absolutism is the point. He wants the reader to feel the cost of default living, to treat conformity not as harmless politeness but as a slow surrender of the self. In Cooper's world, the average life isn't tragic because it's poor or obscure; it's tragic because it's unchosen.
The subtext is a distinctly American anxiety and ambition. Writing in the early republic, Cooper watched a nation invent itself while also flattening people into respectable sameness: churchgoing propriety, civic pieties, the pressure to be "one of us". His frontier fiction romanticized figures who stand apart from settled society, and this line reads like the moral thesis behind that aesthetic. Individuality becomes a kind of ethical courage, not mere quirkiness: the willingness to risk misunderstanding, ridicule, even exile from the communal story.
His rhetoric is bluntly binary, almost Puritan in its consequence. "No other existence" versus "greatness"; "common" versus "mediocrity". That absolutism is the point. He wants the reader to feel the cost of default living, to treat conformity not as harmless politeness but as a slow surrender of the self. In Cooper's world, the average life isn't tragic because it's poor or obscure; it's tragic because it's unchosen.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Improvement |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List
