"All things will be produced in superior quantity and quality, and with greater ease, when each man works at a single occupation, in accordance with his natural gifts, and at the right moment, without meddling with anything else"
About this Quote
Plato ties productivity to a vision of human nature and civic order. The line emerges from the Republic, where Socrates builds a city by assigning each person one craft according to innate aptitude. A shoemaker should make shoes, a farmer should farm, and neither should try to be a jack-of-all-trades. The promise is twofold: superior output in both quantity and quality, and ease that comes from mastery rather than constant switching. Craft is not only a metaphor for politics; it is the mechanism by which a just city takes shape.
Natural gifts signal a belief in differentiated capacities. Plato treats aptitude as real and morally significant, not merely a matter of preference. The ideal is not unlimited self-invention but the discovery of one’s proper work. He couples this with timeliness. The right moment evokes kairos, the judgment to act at the point when knowledge and conditions align. Even the finest skill misfires if exercised out of season. Hence the warning against meddling: the Greek term polypragmosyne names the restless busybody who disrupts order by doing what is not his to do. Justice, for Plato, is a harmony in which each part performs its function without trespass.
The claim anticipates the economic doctrine of the division of labor later praised by Adam Smith, yet the aim differs. Smith emphasizes efficiency and wealth; Plato subordinates efficiency to moral and civic aims. Specialization supports a stable hierarchy culminating in philosopher-rulers who govern because their nature fits knowledge of the good. The producer classes specialize not for private gain but for the health of the whole.
There is a cost worth scrutinizing. Rigid assignment can ossify roles, suppressing aspiration and undervaluing learning across domains. Plato acknowledges education as crucial, suggesting that discovering true gifts requires careful cultivation. Still, the core insight remains provocative: excellence grows when work fits nature and timing, and communities flourish when ambition is channeled into well-matched, well-timed tasks rather than scattered pursuits.
Natural gifts signal a belief in differentiated capacities. Plato treats aptitude as real and morally significant, not merely a matter of preference. The ideal is not unlimited self-invention but the discovery of one’s proper work. He couples this with timeliness. The right moment evokes kairos, the judgment to act at the point when knowledge and conditions align. Even the finest skill misfires if exercised out of season. Hence the warning against meddling: the Greek term polypragmosyne names the restless busybody who disrupts order by doing what is not his to do. Justice, for Plato, is a harmony in which each part performs its function without trespass.
The claim anticipates the economic doctrine of the division of labor later praised by Adam Smith, yet the aim differs. Smith emphasizes efficiency and wealth; Plato subordinates efficiency to moral and civic aims. Specialization supports a stable hierarchy culminating in philosopher-rulers who govern because their nature fits knowledge of the good. The producer classes specialize not for private gain but for the health of the whole.
There is a cost worth scrutinizing. Rigid assignment can ossify roles, suppressing aspiration and undervaluing learning across domains. Plato acknowledges education as crucial, suggesting that discovering true gifts requires careful cultivation. Still, the core insight remains provocative: excellence grows when work fits nature and timing, and communities flourish when ambition is channeled into well-matched, well-timed tasks rather than scattered pursuits.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work Ethic |
|---|
More Quotes by Plato
Add to List
