"An extraordinary amount of arrogance is present in any claim of having been the first in inventing something"
About this Quote
Claims of being first often hide the crowded lineage of ideas. Mandelbrot points to the vanity that creeps into priority battles, where novelty is treated as an absolute rather than a culmination. Creativity usually works by recombination, translation, and refinement; the spark that appears new emerges from a field already thick with embers. To insist on primacy is to ignore the mentors, rivals, precursors, forgotten papers, and enabling technologies that make a breakthrough possible.
The history of science and technology is full of multiples: Newton and Leibniz with calculus, Darwin and Wallace with natural selection, Edison and Swan with the light bulb. Sociologist Robert Merton showed that simultaneous discovery is common when the intellectual and material conditions are ripe. Under such conditions, claiming to be first says as much about the claimant’s ego as it does about the achievement.
Mandelbrot’s own career embodies this humility. Celebrated as the father of fractal geometry, he built on a century of work by Cantor, Koch, Hausdorff, Julia, and Fatou. What he did, with the aid of computers and a cross-disciplinary eye, was to synthesize, visualize, name, and popularize a scattered set of ideas, making them vivid for physicists, economists, artists, and the broader public. The now-iconic Mandelbrot set owes its fame not to being the first appearance of complex dynamics, but to a compelling articulation that invited others to explore.
The line also critiques the way incentives shape credit. Patents, tenure, and headlines reward novelty and priority, not patient cumulative labor. That economy of prestige encourages overreach and erases contributions, especially from marginalized voices. A healthier stance treats originality as relational: first to connect domains, first to make a method usable, first to communicate it widely. By shifting attention from ownership to stewardship, we honor the network that produces discovery and keep arrogance from narrowing the story of how knowledge grows.
The history of science and technology is full of multiples: Newton and Leibniz with calculus, Darwin and Wallace with natural selection, Edison and Swan with the light bulb. Sociologist Robert Merton showed that simultaneous discovery is common when the intellectual and material conditions are ripe. Under such conditions, claiming to be first says as much about the claimant’s ego as it does about the achievement.
Mandelbrot’s own career embodies this humility. Celebrated as the father of fractal geometry, he built on a century of work by Cantor, Koch, Hausdorff, Julia, and Fatou. What he did, with the aid of computers and a cross-disciplinary eye, was to synthesize, visualize, name, and popularize a scattered set of ideas, making them vivid for physicists, economists, artists, and the broader public. The now-iconic Mandelbrot set owes its fame not to being the first appearance of complex dynamics, but to a compelling articulation that invited others to explore.
The line also critiques the way incentives shape credit. Patents, tenure, and headlines reward novelty and priority, not patient cumulative labor. That economy of prestige encourages overreach and erases contributions, especially from marginalized voices. A healthier stance treats originality as relational: first to connect domains, first to make a method usable, first to communicate it widely. By shifting attention from ownership to stewardship, we honor the network that produces discovery and keep arrogance from narrowing the story of how knowledge grows.
Quote Details
| Topic | Humility |
|---|
More Quotes by Benoit
Add to List
