"Certain remakes are great. Carpenter's The Thing is better than the original"

In the quote by Alex Winter, "Certain remakes are excellent. Carpenter's The Thing is much better than the original", a number of points are being articulated concerning the nature and potential of film remakes. Winter initially acknowledges that while the idea of remaking films is often consulted with apprehension, there are circumstances where a remake not only honors the initial but surpasses it in quality, storytelling, and effect. He uses John Carpenter's "The Thing" as a prime example.

John Carpenter's 1982 film "The Thing" is a remake of the 1951 film, "The Thing from Another World", which itself was based on the novella "Who Goes There?" by John W. Campbell. This remake is often celebrated for its ingenious unique effects, tense environment, and mental depth. Unlike numerous remakes that simply capitalize on the nostalgia or brand recognition of the original, Carpenter's movie transforms and elevates the source material.

Winter season's assertion implies that an effective remake needs a fresh vision and a thoughtful reimagining that appreciates the initial while contributing something new. Carpenter's "The Thing" was not just highly exceptional; it delved much deeper into styles of paranoia and mistrust, showing the cultural anxieties of its time with a vitality that the initial possibly did not fully explore.

Furthermore, Winter's quote implicitly acknowledges the capacity for remakes to function as homages that boost the legacy of their predecessors. Carpenter's film has actually gained a significant cult following, perhaps more popular and enduring than that of the original. This challenges the typical understanding that remakes are naturally inferior or unoriginal.

In summary, Winter's quote encapsulates the idea that remakes can be transformative and significant in their influence on movie theater-- echoing Carpenter's "The Thing", which stands as a paradigmatic example of a remake that not just appreciates but transcends its origins.