"Circumstances are beyond human control, but our conduct is in our own power"
About this Quote
Disraeli’s line is a political maxim disguised as moral reassurance: history will do what it wants, but you still have to answer for how you move through it. Coming from a statesman who built his career inside a volatile 19th-century Britain of reform bills, imperial ambition, and class unrest, it reads less like stoic self-help and more like an operating manual for power under pressure. Events may be “beyond human control,” he concedes, which quietly acknowledges the limits of even the most charismatic leader. But the pivot matters: “our conduct” is the one domain where legitimacy can be earned or lost.
The subtext is accountability with an escape hatch. Disraeli absolves leaders from omnipotence while denying them the right to plead helplessness. You can’t stop the crisis, the market, the war, the scandal. You can choose whether you lie, panic, scapegoat, or govern. That’s not just ethics; it’s a survival strategy in public life, where voters and rivals often judge character through the narrow keyhole of response.
Rhetorically, it works because it splits fate into two compartments: circumstance (chaotic, impersonal, almost natural) and conduct (deliberate, owned). The phrase “in our own power” lands like a gavel. It turns agency into duty, and duty into a measurable standard. In an era obsessed with respectability and responsibility, Disraeli offers a neat credo: you may not control the storm, but you will be held to account for how you steer.
The subtext is accountability with an escape hatch. Disraeli absolves leaders from omnipotence while denying them the right to plead helplessness. You can’t stop the crisis, the market, the war, the scandal. You can choose whether you lie, panic, scapegoat, or govern. That’s not just ethics; it’s a survival strategy in public life, where voters and rivals often judge character through the narrow keyhole of response.
Rhetorically, it works because it splits fate into two compartments: circumstance (chaotic, impersonal, almost natural) and conduct (deliberate, owned). The phrase “in our own power” lands like a gavel. It turns agency into duty, and duty into a measurable standard. In an era obsessed with respectability and responsibility, Disraeli offers a neat credo: you may not control the storm, but you will be held to account for how you steer.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by Benjamin
Add to List





