"Creation implies authority in the sense of originator. The possibility of a 'Fall' is implied in a Covenant insofar as the idea of a Covenant implies the possibility of its being violated"
About this Quote
Burke is doing what he does best: taking ideas that sound lofty and making them look like machinery. “Creation implies authority” isn’t a pious claim; it’s a structural one. The moment you name an origin, you smuggle in an originator, and with that comes hierarchy. Creation, in Burke’s dramatistic sense, is never just about making something; it’s about who gets to define the terms of what’s been made. Authorship becomes governance. If someone (a god, a founder, a nation) can say “I made this,” they can also say “therefore, you owe me.”
The second sentence tightens the screw. A “Covenant” sounds like mutual agreement, but Burke points out its built-in trap: a covenant only matters because it can be broken. Obligation needs the shadow of transgression to feel real. The “Fall” isn’t a regrettable accident that might happen after the rules are set; it’s implied by the very existence of rules framed as sacred bonds. Once you define a promise, you manufacture the possibility - and the drama - of betrayal.
The subtext is political as much as theological. Societies that ground themselves in founding stories and covenants (religious communities, constitutional nations, revolutionary movements) also generate the conditions for guilt, punishment, and redemption narratives. Burke is warning that moral order is never neutral: it comes preloaded with authority, and it sustains itself by keeping violation imaginable. That’s why these stories persist - they don’t just explain the world; they script it.
The second sentence tightens the screw. A “Covenant” sounds like mutual agreement, but Burke points out its built-in trap: a covenant only matters because it can be broken. Obligation needs the shadow of transgression to feel real. The “Fall” isn’t a regrettable accident that might happen after the rules are set; it’s implied by the very existence of rules framed as sacred bonds. Once you define a promise, you manufacture the possibility - and the drama - of betrayal.
The subtext is political as much as theological. Societies that ground themselves in founding stories and covenants (religious communities, constitutional nations, revolutionary movements) also generate the conditions for guilt, punishment, and redemption narratives. Burke is warning that moral order is never neutral: it comes preloaded with authority, and it sustains itself by keeping violation imaginable. That’s why these stories persist - they don’t just explain the world; they script it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Kenneth
Add to List
