"Criticize the act, not the person"
About this Quote
In a corporate culture that can turn feedback into a blood sport, "Criticize the act, not the person" reads like a deceptively simple rule with teeth. Mary Kay Ash wasn’t writing from a seminar whiteboard; she was building a sales empire that depended on morale, retention, and a sense of personal dignity. The line works because it’s less about kindness than about control: it separates behavior (changeable, discussable) from identity (sticky, defended). Do that, and you keep people in the conversation instead of triggering the fight-or-flight shame spiral that makes teams brittle.
The subtext is pragmatic and, frankly, shrewd. Ash understood that organizations often punish people for outcomes while pretending they’re evaluating performance. By insisting the critique stay attached to the act, she redirects authority away from character judgments - lazy, difficult, not leadership material - and toward specifics: missed deadline, sloppy pitch, mishandled client. That precision protects the worker, but it also protects the manager. It limits liability, reduces escalation, and makes improvement legible. You can’t coach “you are careless”; you can coach “you sent the wrong invoice.”
Context matters: Ash built Mary Kay in a mid-century business world that routinely infantilized women and moralized their competence. Her maxim pushes back against the personal insult masquerading as professional critique. It’s a philosophy of feedback that doubles as a philosophy of belonging: you can be wrong here without being disposable. That’s not softness; it’s how a high-turnover sales machine becomes a community people won’t easily leave.
The subtext is pragmatic and, frankly, shrewd. Ash understood that organizations often punish people for outcomes while pretending they’re evaluating performance. By insisting the critique stay attached to the act, she redirects authority away from character judgments - lazy, difficult, not leadership material - and toward specifics: missed deadline, sloppy pitch, mishandled client. That precision protects the worker, but it also protects the manager. It limits liability, reduces escalation, and makes improvement legible. You can’t coach “you are careless”; you can coach “you sent the wrong invoice.”
Context matters: Ash built Mary Kay in a mid-century business world that routinely infantilized women and moralized their competence. Her maxim pushes back against the personal insult masquerading as professional critique. It’s a philosophy of feedback that doubles as a philosophy of belonging: you can be wrong here without being disposable. That’s not softness; it’s how a high-turnover sales machine becomes a community people won’t easily leave.
Quote Details
| Topic | Respect |
|---|
More Quotes by Mary
Add to List




