"Don't abuse your friends and expect them to consider it criticism"
About this Quote
The line lands like a newsroom jab: short, unsentimental, and designed to puncture a very specific kind of hypocrisy. Howe, an editor by trade, knew that “criticism” is often the respectable suit worn by plain cruelty. By pairing “abuse” with “expect,” he frames the speaker not as blunt-but-honest, but as entitled - someone who wants the benefits of candor without paying the social cost of care.
The intent is corrective, but not gentle. Howe isn’t defending fragile feelings; he’s defending the moral contract of friendship. Real critique presumes a shared goal (your improvement, your well-being, the relationship’s health). Abuse presumes dominance. The sentence’s sting comes from its refusal to let the abuser launder aggression through the language of truth-telling. It’s an early callout of a dynamic we’d now recognize in “I’m just being honest” culture: the belief that harshness automatically equals authenticity.
There’s also a professional subtext. Editors work in a world where sharp feedback is necessary, but the best of it is precise, bounded, and aimed at the work - not the person. Howe implies that interpersonal criticism should meet a similar standard: accuracy, restraint, and a baseline of respect. If you’re swinging for humiliation, don’t act surprised when the friendship doesn’t treat it as helpful copyediting.
Context matters: late-19th/early-20th century American public life prized plain talk, sometimes to the point of brutality. Howe’s wit draws a line between forthrightness and meanness - and exposes how often people cross it while demanding applause for their “candor.”
The intent is corrective, but not gentle. Howe isn’t defending fragile feelings; he’s defending the moral contract of friendship. Real critique presumes a shared goal (your improvement, your well-being, the relationship’s health). Abuse presumes dominance. The sentence’s sting comes from its refusal to let the abuser launder aggression through the language of truth-telling. It’s an early callout of a dynamic we’d now recognize in “I’m just being honest” culture: the belief that harshness automatically equals authenticity.
There’s also a professional subtext. Editors work in a world where sharp feedback is necessary, but the best of it is precise, bounded, and aimed at the work - not the person. Howe implies that interpersonal criticism should meet a similar standard: accuracy, restraint, and a baseline of respect. If you’re swinging for humiliation, don’t act surprised when the friendship doesn’t treat it as helpful copyediting.
Context matters: late-19th/early-20th century American public life prized plain talk, sometimes to the point of brutality. Howe’s wit draws a line between forthrightness and meanness - and exposes how often people cross it while demanding applause for their “candor.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Friendship |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Edgar
Add to List








