"Don't fall in love with politicians, they're all a disappointment. They can't help it, they just are"

Peggy Noonan's statement about politicians reveals a deep skepticism about the nature of political leadership and the expectations society places on those who govern. Her advice, urging people not to emotionally invest themselves in politicians, speaks to a recurring cycle where public figures garner hope and admiration, only to ultimately prove fallible or even disappointing. The use of the phrase “don’t fall in love” elevates politicians to a pedestal they often cannot sustain, suggesting that emotional attachment clouds judgment and sets the stage for inevitable disillusionment.

Noonan attributes this disappointment not necessarily to malice or incompetence, but to the intrinsic realities of political life. Politicians operate within complex systems riddled with competing interests, bureaucracy, and compromise. The very nature of governance demands negotiation, incremental progress, and frequent trade-offs, which can make steadfast ideals seem impractical or naive when confronted with real-world pressures. Aspiring to perfection in such an environment borders on impossibility, yet the public often projects lofty expectations onto political figures.

Furthermore, the suggestion that “they can’t help it, they just are” recognizes a kind of systemic inevitability. Politicians, regardless of their starting point, excellent intentions, or charisma, face institutional limitations and personal shortcomings. Power exposes flaws, ambition complicates integrity, and the pressure to satisfy a diverse electorate often leads to decisions that frustrate loyal supporters. Noonan’s words highlight the human aspect of politicians: they are as susceptible to error and weakness as any individual.

Her cautionary perspective encourages citizens to engage critically with politics rather than emotionally. By resisting the temptation to idolize leaders, people become less prone to cynicism when leadership falls short. This balanced outlook does not preclude hope or involvement; instead, it invites mature participation, understanding, and a realistic appraisal of those in power.