"Education is not to reform students or amuse them or to make them expert technicians. It is to unsettle their minds, widen their horizons, inflame their intellects, teach them to think straight, if possible"
About this Quote
Hutchins frames education as a dignified kind of disturbance: not self-help, not job training, not even entertainment, but a disciplined provocation. The verbs do the heavy lifting. "Unsettle" rejects the comforting premise that schools exist to make people feel competent and affirmed. Real learning, he implies, begins as a threat to the stories students have been told about the world and about themselves. "Widen" and "inflame" add motion and heat, suggesting education should expand what you can imagine while also making it harder to stay neutral.
The subtext is a rebuke to the instrumental drift of modern schooling. "Expert technicians" sounds like praise in an industrial society; Hutchins uses it like an indictment. Technique without judgment produces skilled compliance: workers who can execute but not question. Even "reform students" gets side-eyed, as if moral polishing is too small and too paternal. He isn't arguing for chaos; he's arguing for rigor aimed at autonomy. "Teach them to think straight, if possible" is a sly concession that clarity is hard, not guaranteed, and certainly not delivered by credentials.
Context matters: Hutchins, as president of the University of Chicago and a champion of Great Books liberal education, fought the 20th century's turn toward specialization and vocationalism. This line reads like a mission statement against the assembly-line university. It also anticipates a present tense problem: a culture that measures education by ROI and treats discomfort as a design flaw. For Hutchins, discomfort is the point - the price of intellectual adulthood.
The subtext is a rebuke to the instrumental drift of modern schooling. "Expert technicians" sounds like praise in an industrial society; Hutchins uses it like an indictment. Technique without judgment produces skilled compliance: workers who can execute but not question. Even "reform students" gets side-eyed, as if moral polishing is too small and too paternal. He isn't arguing for chaos; he's arguing for rigor aimed at autonomy. "Teach them to think straight, if possible" is a sly concession that clarity is hard, not guaranteed, and certainly not delivered by credentials.
Context matters: Hutchins, as president of the University of Chicago and a champion of Great Books liberal education, fought the 20th century's turn toward specialization and vocationalism. This line reads like a mission statement against the assembly-line university. It also anticipates a present tense problem: a culture that measures education by ROI and treats discomfort as a design flaw. For Hutchins, discomfort is the point - the price of intellectual adulthood.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List







