"Emotions have taught mankind to reason"
About this Quote
Reason likes to pose as the sober adult in the room, but Luc de Clapiers - the young French moralist better known as Vauvenargues - flips the hierarchy. "Emotions have taught mankind to reason" is a provocation aimed at the Enlightenment vanity that intellect arrives clean, self-generated, and superior. He suggests the opposite: we learned to think because we first had something at stake.
The line works because it treats emotion not as static feeling but as pressure. Fear forces pattern-recognition; desire invents strategy; love sharpens attention; shame builds a social compass. In that sense, reason is less a pristine faculty than a tool forged under heat. Vauvenargues isn't romanticizing irrationality; he's exposing reason's origin story as profoundly embodied and social. The subtext is mildly accusatory: if your logic pretends to be detached, it's probably smuggling in unacknowledged motives.
Context matters. Writing in early-18th-century France, in the orbit of salons and moral philosophy, Vauvenargues is pushing back against the period's fashionable confidence that human beings can be engineered by pure rational principles. His aphorism echoes a tradition of French maxims that puncture self-image with a needle: the mind congratulates itself for autonomy, while the heart quietly pays the bills.
Read now, it lands as an argument about how people actually change. Facts rarely reorganize a life; feelings do, and then the mind arrives to build scaffolding. Reason may adjudicate, but emotion is often the first witness.
The line works because it treats emotion not as static feeling but as pressure. Fear forces pattern-recognition; desire invents strategy; love sharpens attention; shame builds a social compass. In that sense, reason is less a pristine faculty than a tool forged under heat. Vauvenargues isn't romanticizing irrationality; he's exposing reason's origin story as profoundly embodied and social. The subtext is mildly accusatory: if your logic pretends to be detached, it's probably smuggling in unacknowledged motives.
Context matters. Writing in early-18th-century France, in the orbit of salons and moral philosophy, Vauvenargues is pushing back against the period's fashionable confidence that human beings can be engineered by pure rational principles. His aphorism echoes a tradition of French maxims that puncture self-image with a needle: the mind congratulates itself for autonomy, while the heart quietly pays the bills.
Read now, it lands as an argument about how people actually change. Facts rarely reorganize a life; feelings do, and then the mind arrives to build scaffolding. Reason may adjudicate, but emotion is often the first witness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|---|
| Source | "Emotions have taught mankind to reason." , attributed to Luc de Clapiers, Marquis de Vauvenargues; cited in collections of his "Réflexions et maximes" (common English translation of a Vauvenargues maxim). |
More Quotes by Luc
Add to List
