"Every actual State is corrupt. Good men must not obey laws too well"
About this Quote
Emerson doesn’t offer comfort here; he offers a provocation dressed as moral hygiene. “Every actual State is corrupt” isn’t a tantrum against politics so much as an acid test for conscience. The word “actual” matters: not the State as an ideal (social contract, public good, civics-class abstraction) but the State as it exists, staffed by fallible people, lubricated by compromise, and incentivized to preserve itself. Corruption, in this frame, is structural before it’s scandalous.
Then comes the real grenade: “Good men must not obey laws too well.” Emerson flips the usual Victorian equation of virtue with compliance. “Too well” is doing heavy work. He’s not urging chaos; he’s warning against the moral anesthesia that comes from perfect procedural loyalty. A society can run smoothly while doing ugly things, especially when its best citizens outsource judgment to rule-following. Obedience becomes a way to feel innocent.
The context is Emerson’s broader American individualism and his proximity to abolitionist agitation in the mid-19th century, when legality and justice were openly at war. Fugitive Slave laws were, after all, laws. Emerson’s intent is to legitimize dissent not as selfishness but as civic maintenance: the State needs friction from principled people to keep it from sliding into its default setting - self-protective, majority-serving, morally numb.
The subtext is bracing: if you’re “good” and everything feels legally tidy, you might be part of the problem. The ethical life, Emerson suggests, requires a calibrated disobedience - the courage to be inconvenient when the law asks for complicity.
Then comes the real grenade: “Good men must not obey laws too well.” Emerson flips the usual Victorian equation of virtue with compliance. “Too well” is doing heavy work. He’s not urging chaos; he’s warning against the moral anesthesia that comes from perfect procedural loyalty. A society can run smoothly while doing ugly things, especially when its best citizens outsource judgment to rule-following. Obedience becomes a way to feel innocent.
The context is Emerson’s broader American individualism and his proximity to abolitionist agitation in the mid-19th century, when legality and justice were openly at war. Fugitive Slave laws were, after all, laws. Emerson’s intent is to legitimize dissent not as selfishness but as civic maintenance: the State needs friction from principled people to keep it from sliding into its default setting - self-protective, majority-serving, morally numb.
The subtext is bracing: if you’re “good” and everything feels legally tidy, you might be part of the problem. The ethical life, Emerson suggests, requires a calibrated disobedience - the courage to be inconvenient when the law asks for complicity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | From the essay "Politics" by Ralph Waldo Emerson (commonly cited source for this quotation). |
More Quotes by Ralph
Add to List








