"Every genuine boy is a rebel and an anarch. If he were allowed to develop according to his own instincts, his own inclinations, society would undergo such a radical transformation as to make the adult revolutionary cower and cringe"
About this Quote
Childhood, in Holmes's telling, is the last anarchist sanctuary: a stage of life untrained in the polite frauds that keep adult society humming. Calling the "genuine boy" a "rebel and an anarch" isn't nostalgic praise; it's a provocation aimed at the grown-ups who like their kids spirited in theory and compliant in practice. Holmes frames instinct as a kind of political force. Left unedited, a child's impulses would not simply misbehave; they'd rewrite the rules.
The sentence works because it flatters and indicts at the same time. It flatters youth as authentic and fearless, then indicts society as a system so brittle it relies on domestication to survive. "Allowed to develop" carries the real accusation: children aren't merely raised, they're managed. The verb smuggles in a critique of schooling, manners, and every institution that trains raw desire into "reasonable" ambition.
Holmes's punchline is the turnaround: the "adult revolutionary" - supposedly the radical - would "cower and cringe" before an unfiltered child's imagination. That's slyly cynical. He suggests adult politics, even at its most militant, is still adult: bound to programs, slogans, and acceptable futures. A boy's rebellion is prior to ideology; it's chaos, curiosity, refusal. Holmes wrote in an era when American modernity was professionalizing everything, including personality. The line reads like a warning from a journalist watching conformity become a civic virtue: the most disruptive energy isn't in manifestos, it's in the untutored human being we spend years training out of ourselves.
The sentence works because it flatters and indicts at the same time. It flatters youth as authentic and fearless, then indicts society as a system so brittle it relies on domestication to survive. "Allowed to develop" carries the real accusation: children aren't merely raised, they're managed. The verb smuggles in a critique of schooling, manners, and every institution that trains raw desire into "reasonable" ambition.
Holmes's punchline is the turnaround: the "adult revolutionary" - supposedly the radical - would "cower and cringe" before an unfiltered child's imagination. That's slyly cynical. He suggests adult politics, even at its most militant, is still adult: bound to programs, slogans, and acceptable futures. A boy's rebellion is prior to ideology; it's chaos, curiosity, refusal. Holmes wrote in an era when American modernity was professionalizing everything, including personality. The line reads like a warning from a journalist watching conformity become a civic virtue: the most disruptive energy isn't in manifestos, it's in the untutored human being we spend years training out of ourselves.
Quote Details
| Topic | Youth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List










