"Everything has to be pulling weight in a short story for it to be really of the first order"

Tobias Wolff's quote, "Everything needs to be pulling weight in a narrative for it to be really of the first order", highlights the requirement for accuracy and purposefulness in the craft of short story writing. In this context, "pulling weight" recommends that every component of the narrative should contribute significantly to the overall effect and cohesion of the story.

In a short story, unlike in a novel, there is limited area to develop themes, characters, and plots. For this reason, every word, character, and scene must be thoroughly picked to serve the dual function of forwarding the plot and enhancing the thematic depth of the narrative. Wolff stresses that for a short story to really stick out, or reach "the first order", it must exhibit a level of craftsmanship where redundancy and unneeded elements are removed.

Characters need to be drawn with accuracy; their dialogue and actions need to reveal extensive facts or disputes in a succinct manner. Setting, tone, and language ought to work in consistency, setting the backdrop for the narrative while underscoring its emotional and thematic undercurrents. Significance and imagery, if utilized, ought to resonate on multiple levels, boosting the reader's understanding without unnecessary description.

Wolff challenges writers to disrobe their stories to their important parts, guaranteeing that every part is essential. This strenuous approach not only respects the reader's time however likewise appreciates the art type itself, as stories that accomplish this economy of expression typically leave an enduring impression through their clarity and strength. Ultimately, Wolff is advocating for a disciplined meticulousness that changes a story from mere home entertainment into a profound and resonant experience. Such stories linger with the reader, embodying a narrative effectiveness that is both difficult and satisfying to accomplish.