"For a solo work I need a definite idea. For the present I have none"
About this Quote
The line lands like a private confession overheard in a public hallway: a major composer admitting that the engine won’t start without a key. Schnittke’s “definite idea” isn’t a cute bit of inspiration-talk; it’s a demand for structural necessity. A solo work strips away the camouflage of ensemble color and theatrical gesture. With one performer exposed, every bar has to justify its existence. The subtext is almost ethical: without a governing concept, writing becomes decoration, and decoration is the one sin solo music can’t hide.
It also reads as a quiet flex. Schnittke, famous for polystylism and collage, is often caricatured as someone who can freely splice idioms at will. Here he draws a boundary: even the most eclectic voice needs an organizing pressure, a reason to choose this material rather than any other. “For the present I have none” is blunt, unsentimental, and revealingly unromantic. No myth of the tortured genius, no performative agony. Just a working artist stating the conditions under which he can be honest.
Context matters: Schnittke wrote under late Soviet cultural constraints, and later under the physical constraints of illness. In both cases, the question of what can be said, and how directly, is never abstract. A “definite idea” becomes more than a theme; it’s a survival tool, a way to make music that isn’t merely permitted or merely possible, but necessary.
It also reads as a quiet flex. Schnittke, famous for polystylism and collage, is often caricatured as someone who can freely splice idioms at will. Here he draws a boundary: even the most eclectic voice needs an organizing pressure, a reason to choose this material rather than any other. “For the present I have none” is blunt, unsentimental, and revealingly unromantic. No myth of the tortured genius, no performative agony. Just a working artist stating the conditions under which he can be honest.
Context matters: Schnittke wrote under late Soviet cultural constraints, and later under the physical constraints of illness. In both cases, the question of what can be said, and how directly, is never abstract. A “definite idea” becomes more than a theme; it’s a survival tool, a way to make music that isn’t merely permitted or merely possible, but necessary.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Alfred
Add to List




