"God must have been on leave during the Holocaust"
About this Quote
A line like this is designed to offend the easy comfort of piety, not faith itself. Wiesenthal, who survived the camps and later made a life’s work of hunting Nazi perpetrators, isn’t offering an abstract theological puzzle. He’s staging a moral interruption. “On leave” is almost bureaucratic phrasing, the language of offices and schedules, and that’s the point: it drags God down into the same administrative universe that enabled genocide through stamped papers, timetables, quotas, and polite compliance. The casualness is acid.
The intent is twofold. First, it refuses the retroactive consolation that “there was a reason,” or that suffering is secretly balanced by providence. If God was “on leave,” then the Holocaust can’t be safely metabolized into a story with a benevolent arc. Second, it pressures the listener toward human responsibility. If the divine was absent, then the only remaining actors are people: perpetrators, bystanders, rescuers, the international community that stalled and hedged. The subtext is an indictment of every institution that hid behind ritual language while bodies piled up.
Context matters: postwar Europe was thick with silence, amnesia, and recycled respectability. Wiesenthal’s activism depended on memory that wouldn’t behave, guilt that wouldn’t dissolve, and justice that refused to wait for metaphysics. The line functions as a provocation to moral seriousness: if there is any “presence” after Auschwitz, it has to look like accountability, testimony, and the stubborn refusal to let atrocity become an episode with a comforting moral.
The intent is twofold. First, it refuses the retroactive consolation that “there was a reason,” or that suffering is secretly balanced by providence. If God was “on leave,” then the Holocaust can’t be safely metabolized into a story with a benevolent arc. Second, it pressures the listener toward human responsibility. If the divine was absent, then the only remaining actors are people: perpetrators, bystanders, rescuers, the international community that stalled and hedged. The subtext is an indictment of every institution that hid behind ritual language while bodies piled up.
Context matters: postwar Europe was thick with silence, amnesia, and recycled respectability. Wiesenthal’s activism depended on memory that wouldn’t behave, guilt that wouldn’t dissolve, and justice that refused to wait for metaphysics. The line functions as a provocation to moral seriousness: if there is any “presence” after Auschwitz, it has to look like accountability, testimony, and the stubborn refusal to let atrocity become an episode with a comforting moral.
Quote Details
| Topic | God |
|---|
More Quotes by Simon
Add to List




