"God, that dumping ground of our dreams"
About this Quote
A jolt of irony hides in that phrase: God as the place where human beings unload their most extravagant wishes, spotless ideals, and secret longings. The image is not a shrine but a landfill. Dreams go there when they are too grand, too contradictory, or too costly to pursue in the rough medium of life. Rather than transform them into action, we cast them upward and call them sacred. Jean Rostand, a biologist and aphorist steeped in rational inquiry, is sharpening an old insight: what we worship is often an outward projection of what we lack or fear we cannot attain. Feuerbach called it the deification of human essence; Freud called it wish-fulfillment; Rostand gives it the sting of civic language, a dumping ground, to expose both the convenience and the neglect that follow.
The phrase also pushes against the God-of-the-gaps reflex. Where understanding falters, or where ethics feel too demanding, a divine ledger is invoked to balance the account. Mercy, justice, immortality, cosmic fairness: all the beautiful impossibilities go into that repository, tidy and consoling, while the world remains as it is. Rostand’s naturalist perspective makes this abdication look especially costly. If the best parts of us are exported to heaven, who will cultivate them on earth? The metaphor implies a double loss: the dreams are sanitized of their risks and obligations, and human agency shrinks in the shadow of a being imagined to carry them for us.
There is no crude sneer here at faith as such; the barb lands at complacency. The line urges a reversal: reclaim what has been dumped. Pull those dreams back from their celestial landfill and test them in the laboratory of reality, with all the compromise, patience, and responsibility that entails. Whether one believes in God or not, the task remains the same: stop offloading aspirations, and make them answerable to our hands, our institutions, and our time.
The phrase also pushes against the God-of-the-gaps reflex. Where understanding falters, or where ethics feel too demanding, a divine ledger is invoked to balance the account. Mercy, justice, immortality, cosmic fairness: all the beautiful impossibilities go into that repository, tidy and consoling, while the world remains as it is. Rostand’s naturalist perspective makes this abdication look especially costly. If the best parts of us are exported to heaven, who will cultivate them on earth? The metaphor implies a double loss: the dreams are sanitized of their risks and obligations, and human agency shrinks in the shadow of a being imagined to carry them for us.
There is no crude sneer here at faith as such; the barb lands at complacency. The line urges a reversal: reclaim what has been dumped. Pull those dreams back from their celestial landfill and test them in the laboratory of reality, with all the compromise, patience, and responsibility that entails. Whether one believes in God or not, the task remains the same: stop offloading aspirations, and make them answerable to our hands, our institutions, and our time.
Quote Details
| Topic | God |
|---|
More Quotes by Jean
Add to List




