"I don't take criticism lying down"
About this Quote
A general doesn’t get to treat criticism as a parlor game. “I don’t take criticism lying down” is Westmoreland turning the vocabulary of the battlefield into a posture for public life: upright, combative, refusing the optics of surrender. The line works because it’s both physical and moral. “Lying down” evokes defeat, weakness, even death; rejecting it signals stamina and control, the kind of toughness a commander is expected to project even when the fight has shifted from jungle terrain to TV studios and congressional hearing rooms.
The subtext is defensive, but disciplined. Westmoreland isn’t claiming infallibility; he’s insisting that critique itself is another front, and he intends to meet it as he would an enemy advance: head-on, with counterargument, with authority. That matters in the late-20th-century context where the military’s legitimacy was increasingly mediated by journalists, polling, and televised footage. Vietnam turned generals into public figures and strategy into spectacle. For Westmoreland especially, criticism wasn’t abstract. It arrived as accusations of misleading optimism, body-count metrics replacing coherent political aims, and later the bruising “credibility gap” narrative that stuck to the war like humidity.
There’s also a subtle bid for sympathy. The phrase implies he’s been hit - perhaps unfairly - and invites the audience to respect the bruises while admiring the refusal to stay down. It’s pride, yes, but also a plea for the one currency commanders can’t easily requisition: trust.
The subtext is defensive, but disciplined. Westmoreland isn’t claiming infallibility; he’s insisting that critique itself is another front, and he intends to meet it as he would an enemy advance: head-on, with counterargument, with authority. That matters in the late-20th-century context where the military’s legitimacy was increasingly mediated by journalists, polling, and televised footage. Vietnam turned generals into public figures and strategy into spectacle. For Westmoreland especially, criticism wasn’t abstract. It arrived as accusations of misleading optimism, body-count metrics replacing coherent political aims, and later the bruising “credibility gap” narrative that stuck to the war like humidity.
There’s also a subtle bid for sympathy. The phrase implies he’s been hit - perhaps unfairly - and invites the audience to respect the bruises while admiring the refusal to stay down. It’s pride, yes, but also a plea for the one currency commanders can’t easily requisition: trust.
Quote Details
| Topic | Leadership |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List
