"If at first you don't succeed... so much for skydiving"
About this Quote
Gallows humor lives on timing, and Henny Youngman’s line is basically a perfect little mousetrap: it lures you in with a wholesome, self-improvement cliche and then snaps shut with the reminder that some failures are final. The setup is a phrase your brain finishes automatically, the kind of motivational boilerplate that turns setbacks into character-building anecdotes. Youngman hijacks that familiarity, then drops you (literally) into a context where “try again” is absurd. Comedy, here, is the collision between cultural script and physical reality.
The intent isn’t to dunk on skydiving so much as to puncture the American optimism industry. “If at first you don’t succeed” assumes a world where consequences are mild, where persistence is always available as a second act. Skydiving introduces a hard limit: sometimes you don’t get the luxury of growth. The laugh comes from that sudden recalibration - from inspirational poster to coroner’s report in eight words.
Youngman’s broader comedic context matters. As a king of one-liners, he specialized in speed and misdirection: jokes that arrive pre-packaged, like verbal trapdoors. This one also reflects mid-century stand-up’s affection for deadpan morbidity, when mainstream comics could flirt with danger and death as long as it was tidy, brisk, and impersonal. No gore, no grief, just a crisp reminder that platitudes don’t apply evenly. The cynicism is gentle but pointed: motivation is easy to preach when the stakes are hypothetical.
The intent isn’t to dunk on skydiving so much as to puncture the American optimism industry. “If at first you don’t succeed” assumes a world where consequences are mild, where persistence is always available as a second act. Skydiving introduces a hard limit: sometimes you don’t get the luxury of growth. The laugh comes from that sudden recalibration - from inspirational poster to coroner’s report in eight words.
Youngman’s broader comedic context matters. As a king of one-liners, he specialized in speed and misdirection: jokes that arrive pre-packaged, like verbal trapdoors. This one also reflects mid-century stand-up’s affection for deadpan morbidity, when mainstream comics could flirt with danger and death as long as it was tidy, brisk, and impersonal. No gore, no grief, just a crisp reminder that platitudes don’t apply evenly. The cynicism is gentle but pointed: motivation is easy to preach when the stakes are hypothetical.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Henny
Add to List
