"I'll play it first and tell you what it is later"
About this Quote
Miles Davis isn’t dodging explanation here; he’s staging a power move against the whole idea that art needs permission slips. “I’ll play it first and tell you what it is later” is a musician insisting that meaning isn’t a press release. It arrives as sound, as sensation, as risk. The order matters: first the experience, then the label. Davis knew labels can be a cage - bebop, cool, modal, fusion - useful for record stores and critics, suffocating for artists who keep mutating.
The intent is practical and defiant. In the studio and onstage, Davis cultivated a culture where players had to listen harder than they wanted to. He gave sparse directions, forced musicians into the present tense, and made uncertainty productive. That’s the subtext: if you need the map before you start walking, you’ll never find a new route. “Tell you what it is later” also carries a sly jab at gatekeepers who demand concepts upfront, as if innovation must submit an outline before it can happen.
Contextually, it fits an era when jazz was being dissected in real time - critics narrating movements, audiences policing authenticity, the marketplace turning scenes into brands. Davis flips the script. He’s not anti-intellectual; he’s anti-preemption. Explanation becomes a postgame interview, not the playbook. The line doubles as a creative ethic and a listening challenge: trust your ear first, and let the category scramble to catch up.
The intent is practical and defiant. In the studio and onstage, Davis cultivated a culture where players had to listen harder than they wanted to. He gave sparse directions, forced musicians into the present tense, and made uncertainty productive. That’s the subtext: if you need the map before you start walking, you’ll never find a new route. “Tell you what it is later” also carries a sly jab at gatekeepers who demand concepts upfront, as if innovation must submit an outline before it can happen.
Contextually, it fits an era when jazz was being dissected in real time - critics narrating movements, audiences policing authenticity, the marketplace turning scenes into brands. Davis flips the script. He’s not anti-intellectual; he’s anti-preemption. Explanation becomes a postgame interview, not the playbook. The line doubles as a creative ethic and a listening challenge: trust your ear first, and let the category scramble to catch up.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | "I'll play it first and tell you what it is later" — Miles Davis; cited on Wikiquote, 'Miles Davis' page. |
More Quotes by Miles
Add to List





