"I'm not going to get into the ring with Tolstoy"
About this Quote
When Hemingway remarks, "I'm not going to get into the ring with Tolstoy", he draws upon the imagery of boxing as a metaphor for literary competition. The reference to "the ring" suggests an arena where writers grapple for supremacy, striving to outdo one another in craft, breadth, and influence. Tolstoy, for Hemingway, represents a towering figure in world literature, a writer whose prowess in the art of the novel is almost unassailable. By refusing to "get into the ring" with Tolstoy, Hemingway acknowledges both humility and a pragmatic awareness of his own place within the pantheon of writers.
This statement reflects Hemingway’s attitude toward literary giants and the futility of rivalry with the greatest masters of the form. Rather than attempt to surpass Tolstoy’s monumental achievements, his psychological insight, his sweeping scope, his commanding style, Hemingway chooses to pursue his own artistic path. The implication is not one of defeat, but of respect, and a recognition that each writer must find his own voice and measure his success according to his own standards.
Such a perspective hints at Hemingway’s broader philosophy on literature and greatness. He absorbed much from his predecessors but shunned comparative ambition as a creative trap, seeing it as potentially paralyzing or inauthentic. Striving merely to compete with someone like Tolstoy risks losing sight of one's individuality, diminishing what is distinctive rather than cultivating it. Hemingway signals here that true creative achievement lies in authenticity and honesty of expression, not in outshining others by their standards.
Additionally, the line exemplifies Hemingway’s characteristic directness and pith, eschewing grandiosity. He neither flatters nor belittles himself, but uses frank language to articulate a grounded self-assessment. In doing so, he reveals his reverence for literary tradition, as well as his confidence in pursuing his own literary innovations, unburdened by impossible comparisons.
About the Author