"In the first place, it must be remembered that our point of view in examining the construction of a play will not always coincide with that which we occupy in thinking of its whole dramatic effect"
About this Quote
Bradley is quietly warning you against a critic's favorite vice: mistaking the autopsy for the living body. When you "examine the construction of a play", you occupy a workshop perspective where joints show, seams matter, and causality can be diagrammed. But the audience member sitting in the dark experiences something else entirely: momentum, surprise, dread, relief. His point is not that craft is irrelevant; it is that craft becomes a different object once you start taking it apart.
The phrasing does courtroom work. "It must be remembered" has the gentle force of a judge instructing a jury: not a suggestion, a procedural safeguard. Bradley builds in an assumption about human error - that analysis naturally narrows vision, that the mind, once it starts counting beams, forgets what it felt like to stand under the roof. The subtext is a critique of pedantry: criticism that congratulates itself for identifying a device while missing the device's purpose, which is to produce "whole dramatic effect", a phrase that insists on totality, not parts.
Context matters. Bradley writes in a late-Victorian moment when Shakespeare criticism was getting more systematic, more architectural, and often more moralistic. His reminder is a defense of experience against overconfident method. He is asking readers to practice a kind of double consciousness: to analyze without forfeiting the naïve vantage point the play was built to command.
The phrasing does courtroom work. "It must be remembered" has the gentle force of a judge instructing a jury: not a suggestion, a procedural safeguard. Bradley builds in an assumption about human error - that analysis naturally narrows vision, that the mind, once it starts counting beams, forgets what it felt like to stand under the roof. The subtext is a critique of pedantry: criticism that congratulates itself for identifying a device while missing the device's purpose, which is to produce "whole dramatic effect", a phrase that insists on totality, not parts.
Context matters. Bradley writes in a late-Victorian moment when Shakespeare criticism was getting more systematic, more architectural, and often more moralistic. His reminder is a defense of experience against overconfident method. He is asking readers to practice a kind of double consciousness: to analyze without forfeiting the naïve vantage point the play was built to command.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Andrew
Add to List




