"Insincerity is always weakness; sincerity even in error is strength"
About this Quote
Lewes insists that moral and intellectual strength lies not in never erring, but in being honest about what one believes. Insincerity is a kind of flight from reality: it relies on concealment, manipulation, and the shifting calculations of what will look good rather than what is true. That stance is inherently weak because it cannot withstand scrutiny or correction; it has no stable center and must constantly be propped up. Sincerity, by contrast, shows courage. To be sincere is to accept accountability for ones convictions, to expose oneself to evidence and argument, and to risk being shown wrong. Even when a sincere belief turns out to be mistaken, the disposition that produced it is aligned with growth and reform.
The aphorism also captures a practical epistemology. Error held sincerely is revisable; it invites dialogue, testing, and learning. Falsehood adopted insincerely is insulated from correction by pride or expediency. In social life the consequences are just as stark. Trust depends less on infallibility than on candor. We forgive those who own their misjudgments because they give us something firmer than their conclusions: the assurance that their process is honest. Leaders, friends, and thinkers who are sincere create a climate where truth can surface, where mistakes become data rather than disgrace.
Its roots in Lewes’s Victorian context run deep. A critic and man of science, intimately connected with George Eliot, he championed empirical inquiry and intellectual integrity. The era’s collision of tradition and new knowledge demanded a stance that could absorb shocks without collapsing into cynicism or dogma. Sincerity offered that resilience. It ties character to method: say what you see, be open to what you have not yet seen, and allow reality to correct you. The paradox dissolves: error can be a strength when the soul that commits it is willing to face facts, because that willingness is the precondition for truth. Insincerity, however skillful, has no such path forward.
The aphorism also captures a practical epistemology. Error held sincerely is revisable; it invites dialogue, testing, and learning. Falsehood adopted insincerely is insulated from correction by pride or expediency. In social life the consequences are just as stark. Trust depends less on infallibility than on candor. We forgive those who own their misjudgments because they give us something firmer than their conclusions: the assurance that their process is honest. Leaders, friends, and thinkers who are sincere create a climate where truth can surface, where mistakes become data rather than disgrace.
Its roots in Lewes’s Victorian context run deep. A critic and man of science, intimately connected with George Eliot, he championed empirical inquiry and intellectual integrity. The era’s collision of tradition and new knowledge demanded a stance that could absorb shocks without collapsing into cynicism or dogma. Sincerity offered that resilience. It ties character to method: say what you see, be open to what you have not yet seen, and allow reality to correct you. The paradox dissolves: error can be a strength when the soul that commits it is willing to face facts, because that willingness is the precondition for truth. Insincerity, however skillful, has no such path forward.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List
