"It is a thousand times better to have common sense without education than to have education without common sense"
About this Quote
Ingersoll’s line is a courtroom punch disguised as folksy wisdom: a clean reversal that flatters the jury and needles the credentialed class at the same time. He wasn’t an anti-intellectual; he was an iconoclast with a litigator’s instinct for what persuades. By stacking “a thousand times better” against the tidy symmetry of “without...than...without,” he turns common sense into a moral asset and education into a suspect tool - powerful, but untrustworthy in the wrong hands.
The intent is tactical. In a late-19th-century America drunk on progress, universities, and “expert” authority, Ingersoll (a famous agnostic and public lecturer) is warning that schooling can become a priesthood: polished, insulated, confident, and wrong. “Education without common sense” isn’t ignorance; it’s overconfidence. It’s the person who can quote doctrine, cite precedent, recite Latin, and still miss what’s plainly in front of them - human motives, practical consequences, the messy facts of life that don’t obey systems.
The subtext is populist, but not cheap. Common sense here isn’t mere gut feeling; it’s an ethical realism, a demand that ideas prove their worth outside the classroom. Coming from a lawyer, it’s also a jab at legal formalism: the danger of mistaking procedure for justice, rhetoric for truth, credentials for judgment.
It works because it’s both a compliment and a threat: if your education doesn’t make you wiser in the ordinary world, it’s not an upgrade - it’s a liability.
The intent is tactical. In a late-19th-century America drunk on progress, universities, and “expert” authority, Ingersoll (a famous agnostic and public lecturer) is warning that schooling can become a priesthood: polished, insulated, confident, and wrong. “Education without common sense” isn’t ignorance; it’s overconfidence. It’s the person who can quote doctrine, cite precedent, recite Latin, and still miss what’s plainly in front of them - human motives, practical consequences, the messy facts of life that don’t obey systems.
The subtext is populist, but not cheap. Common sense here isn’t mere gut feeling; it’s an ethical realism, a demand that ideas prove their worth outside the classroom. Coming from a lawyer, it’s also a jab at legal formalism: the danger of mistaking procedure for justice, rhetoric for truth, credentials for judgment.
It works because it’s both a compliment and a threat: if your education doesn’t make you wiser in the ordinary world, it’s not an upgrade - it’s a liability.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List









