"It is better to have loafed and lost, than never to have loafed at all"
About this Quote
Better to waste time and get burned than to have spent your whole life dutifully busy: that is Thurber’s sly little grenade, lobbed with a grin. By parodying Tennyson’s sanctified “better to have loved and lost,” he drags a revered romantic maxim down into the domestic, American terrain of idleness. The joke isn’t just the swap of one noble noun for a lazy one; it’s the way the sentence keeps the original’s high-minded moral structure, as if loafing deserves the same tragic dignity as love.
Thurber’s intent is both comic and corrective. He’s puncturing the Protestant work ethic without delivering a sermon of his own. “Loafed” sounds like a harmless vice, but it’s loaded: leisure as rebellion, daydreaming as a form of self-preservation, unproductivity as a quiet refusal to be measured by output. “Lost” adds bite. It implies there are consequences to opting out - missed promotions, disapproving glances, the itch of guilt. Thurber doesn’t deny that. He just insists the tradeoff is still worth it.
The subtext is a defense of the inner life in a culture that treats downtime as moral failure. Coming out of a period when American modernity was reorganizing people around clocks, offices, and efficiency, Thurber’s line reads like permission disguised as punchline. It works because it flatters the listener’s secret wish - to stop hustling - while keeping the pose of irony, so nobody has to admit they needed the permission.
Thurber’s intent is both comic and corrective. He’s puncturing the Protestant work ethic without delivering a sermon of his own. “Loafed” sounds like a harmless vice, but it’s loaded: leisure as rebellion, daydreaming as a form of self-preservation, unproductivity as a quiet refusal to be measured by output. “Lost” adds bite. It implies there are consequences to opting out - missed promotions, disapproving glances, the itch of guilt. Thurber doesn’t deny that. He just insists the tradeoff is still worth it.
The subtext is a defense of the inner life in a culture that treats downtime as moral failure. Coming out of a period when American modernity was reorganizing people around clocks, offices, and efficiency, Thurber’s line reads like permission disguised as punchline. It works because it flatters the listener’s secret wish - to stop hustling - while keeping the pose of irony, so nobody has to admit they needed the permission.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List
