"It is not in the nature of politics that the best men should be elected. The best men do not want to govern their fellowmen"

In this quote, George MacDonald provides a rather important view of political systems and the nature of leadership. He suggests that the structure and characteristics inherent in politics do not naturally favor the election of the most capable or ethically exemplary individuals. According to MacDonald, there is an intrinsic discrepancy between those who look for power and those who possess the qualities that may make them the best matched for leadership roles.

The declaration implies that politics, as a practice, does not line up with the virtues that specify the "finest" people. The "finest males", as explained by MacDonald, are most likely defined by qualities such as stability, selflessness, and wisdom. Nevertheless, these individuals might be disinclined to take part in the political arena, typically spoiled by compromise, power battles, and sometimes deceit, as these stand in opposition to their concepts.

MacDonald's assertion likewise highlights a philosophical question about power and governance: Why would somebody who is really virtuous and ethical desire to hold power over others? This challenges the concept of management as an aspiration, suggesting that genuinely virtuous individuals may prefer to lead by example or impact from outside the sphere of official political power.

Additionally, the quote can be viewed through the lens of social structures. It questions whether the systems of political systems are naturally flawed, typically enabling those with ambition and persuasive abilities, instead of authentic virtue or competence, to ascend to positions of power. This shows a skepticism towards politics as a meritocratic organization.

In contemporary discourse, this quote might provoke discussions about the necessity of ethical reforms in political recruitment and election procedures, advocating for systems that incentivize authentic public service over individual gain. It also serves as a reminder for citizens to critically evaluate the motivations and character of those who seek to lead, highlighting the importance of informed and diligent participation in democratic processes.