"It is said that desire is a product of the will, but the converse is in fact true: will is a product of desire"
About this Quote
Diderot flips a comforting Enlightenment story on its head: that the rational self sits in the driver’s seat, issuing “will” like orders from a clean, sovereign mind. His reversal is surgical. If will is born from desire, then self-mastery is less command-and-control than after-the-fact narration: we want, and only then do we dignify the wanting with the language of choice, virtue, discipline. It’s a demotion of the heroic ego, and a promotion of appetite, curiosity, libido, ambition - the messy engines polite society prefers to label “temptation.”
The subtext is editorial in the deepest sense. Diderot spent a life compiling, revising, and arguing through the Encyclopedia project: a machine for organizing knowledge and, by extension, organizing people. He understood how often “reason” arrives as a justification, a footnote added to impulses already in motion. The line is not anti-reason so much as suspicious of reason’s PR function. When institutions claim to be guided by “principle,” Diderot invites you to look for the desire underneath: status, control, security, novelty.
There’s also a quiet politics here. If will is downstream of desire, moralizing becomes a weak lever. You don’t reform a society by scolding it into better intentions; you reshape what it wants and what it’s allowed to admit it wants. That’s Diderot’s modernity: less sermon, more diagnosis of how humans actually move.
The subtext is editorial in the deepest sense. Diderot spent a life compiling, revising, and arguing through the Encyclopedia project: a machine for organizing knowledge and, by extension, organizing people. He understood how often “reason” arrives as a justification, a footnote added to impulses already in motion. The line is not anti-reason so much as suspicious of reason’s PR function. When institutions claim to be guided by “principle,” Diderot invites you to look for the desire underneath: status, control, security, novelty.
There’s also a quiet politics here. If will is downstream of desire, moralizing becomes a weak lever. You don’t reform a society by scolding it into better intentions; you reshape what it wants and what it’s allowed to admit it wants. That’s Diderot’s modernity: less sermon, more diagnosis of how humans actually move.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Denis
Add to List













