"It's hard for me to show work while I'm writing, because other people's comments will influence what happens"
About this Quote
Tartt is defending the solitude of the draft, but she’s also quietly describing how fragile a book is before it becomes a book. The line isn’t precious mystique about “the muse”; it’s a pragmatic admission that fiction is built out of choices so contingent that a single raised eyebrow can reroute the entire story. “Show work” sounds almost managerial, like a progress update in an office. Tartt pushes back against that modern expectation that creativity should be transparent, iterative, and crowd-sourced in real time.
The subtext is about power and permeability. Comments don’t just “help” or “hurt”; they colonize. A reader’s reaction becomes a new character in the room, tugging the writer toward reassurance, explanation, likability, trend. Tartt’s sentence is careful: she doesn’t claim comments are wrong, only that they’re influential. Influence is the threat. For a novelist whose books are famously long-gestating and architected, premature feedback is like opening the oven every five minutes: you’re not checking the cake, you’re stopping it from rising.
Context matters, too. Tartt emerged from a literary culture that prized the completed object and the author’s control, but she’s speaking into a world of workshops, beta readers, social media snippets, and content pipelines. The quote reads as a small act of resistance to the “always-on” audience, and a reminder that privacy isn’t just a lifestyle preference; for some artists, it’s the condition that keeps the work from becoming a negotiated settlement.
The subtext is about power and permeability. Comments don’t just “help” or “hurt”; they colonize. A reader’s reaction becomes a new character in the room, tugging the writer toward reassurance, explanation, likability, trend. Tartt’s sentence is careful: she doesn’t claim comments are wrong, only that they’re influential. Influence is the threat. For a novelist whose books are famously long-gestating and architected, premature feedback is like opening the oven every five minutes: you’re not checking the cake, you’re stopping it from rising.
Context matters, too. Tartt emerged from a literary culture that prized the completed object and the author’s control, but she’s speaking into a world of workshops, beta readers, social media snippets, and content pipelines. The quote reads as a small act of resistance to the “always-on” audience, and a reminder that privacy isn’t just a lifestyle preference; for some artists, it’s the condition that keeps the work from becoming a negotiated settlement.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Donna
Add to List




