"It's rather splendid to think of all those great men and women who appear to have presented symptoms that allow us to describe them as bipolar. Whether it's Hemingway, Van Gogh... Robert Schumann has been mentioned... Virginia Woolf, Sylvia Plath... some of them with rather grim ends"
About this Quote
There is a deliberate seduction in Fry’s phrasing: “rather splendid” turns what could be clinical or tragic into something glittering, a parlor-game of genius. As a comedian, he knows the social itch he’s scratching - the urge to turn suffering into narrative capital, to make illness feel like a backstage pass to greatness. The roll call of Hemingway, Van Gogh, Woolf, Plath is doing cultural work, too. These aren’t just examples; they’re brand names in the modern imagination, shorthand for “brilliant, tortured, authentic.” Fry is naming the mythology and letting you feel its pull.
But the sentence pivots on “appear to have presented symptoms,” a careful hedge that both acknowledges the slipperiness of retroactive diagnosis and keeps the tantalizing implication alive. That ambiguity is the subtext: we want the romance of the label without the responsibility of certainty. By saying “allow us to describe them,” Fry quietly points to our participation. This is about us - our need to explain art with pathology, and to make pain legible by pinning it to a disorder.
Then he undercuts the glamour with a blunt corrective: “some of them with rather grim ends.” The understatement lands like a cold cloth. The joke isn’t that suicide and institutionalization are quaint footnotes; it’s that our culture keeps treating them that way. In context, Fry’s intent reads as both identification and warning: yes, there’s an alluring story people tell about bipolar and genius, but the bill comes due, and it isn’t paid in acclaim.
But the sentence pivots on “appear to have presented symptoms,” a careful hedge that both acknowledges the slipperiness of retroactive diagnosis and keeps the tantalizing implication alive. That ambiguity is the subtext: we want the romance of the label without the responsibility of certainty. By saying “allow us to describe them,” Fry quietly points to our participation. This is about us - our need to explain art with pathology, and to make pain legible by pinning it to a disorder.
Then he undercuts the glamour with a blunt corrective: “some of them with rather grim ends.” The understatement lands like a cold cloth. The joke isn’t that suicide and institutionalization are quaint footnotes; it’s that our culture keeps treating them that way. In context, Fry’s intent reads as both identification and warning: yes, there’s an alluring story people tell about bipolar and genius, but the bill comes due, and it isn’t paid in acclaim.
Quote Details
| Topic | Mental Health |
|---|
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List






