"Kings will be tyrants from policy, when subjects are rebels from principle"
About this Quote
Burke compresses a grim political dynamic: when the governed elevate rebellion into a moral creed, the governing will make repression a calculated necessity. Principle and policy become antagonistic mirrors. Subjects who insist that resistance is a duty invite rulers to see severity as prudence, preemption as strategy, and suspicion as the price of survival. The result is an arms race of virtue and caution in which lofty ideals provoke cold, managerial tyranny.
The line arises from Burke’s lifelong campaign for political moderation. He distrusted abstract theories of rights when severed from inherited institutions, habits, and the slow refinements of law. Once obedience is no longer a contingent virtue but a vice, a crown will conclude that leniency is reckless. Fear reshapes incentives: ministers centralize power, expand surveillance, and punish examples to deter imitators. What began as a moral summons to liberty can thus elicit an administrative science of oppression.
Context matters. Burke praised the Glorious Revolution of 1688 as a limited restoration of an old constitution, not a refounding on first principles. He sought conciliation with the American colonists because he read their claims as customary rights within the British tradition. But he recoiled from the French Revolution, where abstract dogma dissolved authority and social bonds. There, he foresaw, kings and committees alike would harden into tyrants because no stable settlement remained to restrain the struggle.
The aphorism does not excuse despotism; it diagnoses reciprocal radicalization. Politics is a web of expectations. Normalize rebellion as virtue and you normalize repression as prudence. Burke’s counsel is to preserve the space where disagreement can be managed without sanctifying insurrection or canonizing force. Constitutional forms, inherited norms, and incremental reform discipline both rulers and subjects. Lose those restraints and principle and policy chase each other into extremes, until liberty is extinguished by the very means invoked to secure it.
The line arises from Burke’s lifelong campaign for political moderation. He distrusted abstract theories of rights when severed from inherited institutions, habits, and the slow refinements of law. Once obedience is no longer a contingent virtue but a vice, a crown will conclude that leniency is reckless. Fear reshapes incentives: ministers centralize power, expand surveillance, and punish examples to deter imitators. What began as a moral summons to liberty can thus elicit an administrative science of oppression.
Context matters. Burke praised the Glorious Revolution of 1688 as a limited restoration of an old constitution, not a refounding on first principles. He sought conciliation with the American colonists because he read their claims as customary rights within the British tradition. But he recoiled from the French Revolution, where abstract dogma dissolved authority and social bonds. There, he foresaw, kings and committees alike would harden into tyrants because no stable settlement remained to restrain the struggle.
The aphorism does not excuse despotism; it diagnoses reciprocal radicalization. Politics is a web of expectations. Normalize rebellion as virtue and you normalize repression as prudence. Burke’s counsel is to preserve the space where disagreement can be managed without sanctifying insurrection or canonizing force. Constitutional forms, inherited norms, and incremental reform discipline both rulers and subjects. Lose those restraints and principle and policy chase each other into extremes, until liberty is extinguished by the very means invoked to secure it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Edmund
Add to List
