"Let's deal with reality. The reality is that we will be reading Miranda rights to the corpse of Osama bin Laden. He will never appear in an American courtroom"
About this Quote
In this statement, Eric Holder, who served as the Attorney General of the United States from 2009 to 2015, is directly resolving the complicated legal and ethical concerns surrounding the capture and prosecution of prominent terrorist figures like Osama bin Laden. Holder implies a strong stance against the possibility of bin Laden being taken alive and recommends the impracticality and even undesirability of putting such a figure through the American legal system.
The expression "checking out Miranda rights to the corpse" is particularly expressive. In the U.S., Miranda rights read to people upon arrest to inform them of their rights to silence and legal counsel. Referencing this procedure with regard to a "corpse" underscores Holder's belief that bin Laden would not be taken alive. This declaration shows a broader understanding that bin Laden was not only too dangerous to be provided the opportunity to stand trial but also that his capture alive would develop domestic and international legal and security challenges.
Additionally, Holder's assertion that bin Laden "will never ever appear in an American courtroom" shows the view that some individuals may be beyond the scope of traditional legal procedures due to the nature and magnitude of their crimes. The declaration can be viewed as an acknowledgment of the limits of the legal system when handling acts of terrorism on such an unmatched scale.
In a broader sense, this quote encapsulates the tension that frequently exists between suitables of justice and realpolitik-- how foundational legal principles need to in some cases be fixed up with immediate security concerns. This viewpoint was particularly relevant in the post-9/ 11 world, where the American legal system was constantly adapting to resolve new dangers while navigating ethical and constitutional responsibilities. Holder's words signal a recognition of this tough balance, highlighting the need to challenge this type of reality when making choices tied to nationwide security and justice.
About the Author