"Memories, imagination, old sentiments, and associations are more readily reached through the sense of smell than through any other channel"
About this Quote
Smell is Holmes's quiet argument for the mind as a bodily thing, not a marble monument of reason. In a single sentence he elevates the most undervalued sense into a kind of backstage pass to the psyche, where "memories, imagination, old sentiments, and associations" live in a cluttered, intimate pile. The list matters: it moves from the factual (memories) to the fabricated (imagination), then into the emotional residue (old sentiments) and finally the almost automatic wiring (associations). He is mapping a whole interior life, then pointing to the nose as its most direct entrance.
The phrasing "more readily reached" is doing the heavy lifting. Holmes isn't claiming smell is nobler; he's claiming it's faster, sneakier, less mediated by self-control. Sight can be curated. Language can be lied through. Smell arrives with fewer defenses, hitting before you can posture. The subtext is almost democratic: the body keeps its own archive, and it can overrule the polished narratives we tell ourselves.
Context sharpens that intent. Holmes lived in a 19th-century culture intoxicated by progress, classification, and rational mastery, even as Romanticism insisted experience was messier than Enlightenment diagrams. As a poet with a physician's proximity to the physical world, he lands between those impulses. Smell becomes his bridge: evidence of how the past persists not as a timeline but as a sudden atmosphere, a private flood triggered by something as small as smoke on a coat or lilacs on warm air.
The phrasing "more readily reached" is doing the heavy lifting. Holmes isn't claiming smell is nobler; he's claiming it's faster, sneakier, less mediated by self-control. Sight can be curated. Language can be lied through. Smell arrives with fewer defenses, hitting before you can posture. The subtext is almost democratic: the body keeps its own archive, and it can overrule the polished narratives we tell ourselves.
Context sharpens that intent. Holmes lived in a 19th-century culture intoxicated by progress, classification, and rational mastery, even as Romanticism insisted experience was messier than Enlightenment diagrams. As a poet with a physician's proximity to the physical world, he lands between those impulses. Smell becomes his bridge: evidence of how the past persists not as a timeline but as a sudden atmosphere, a private flood triggered by something as small as smoke on a coat or lilacs on warm air.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nostalgia |
|---|
More Quotes by Oliver
Add to List
