"Military intelligence is a contradiction in terms"
About this Quote
Groucho Marx turns a bureaucratic phrase into a banana peel. "Military intelligence" sounds like a polished, official category, the kind of term that’s meant to shut down questions: of course the military has intelligence, it has departments and budgets and acronyms. Groucho’s gag works by treating that phrase literally, then snapping it in half. If "intelligence" implies nimbleness, skepticism, and independent thought, the military represents hierarchy, obedience, and standardization. Put them together and you get an oxymoron that punctures authority with one clean pin.
The intent isn’t to claim soldiers are stupid; it’s to mock the institution’s incentive structure. Armies reward following orders, not being right. Information becomes "intelligence" only after it’s been filtered through rank, politics, and the need for clarity - and clarity is often just simplification with a uniform on. Groucho’s line targets the way power prefers certainty, even when reality is messy, and how language helps launder that preference. Call it intelligence and it feels objective; call it a guess and you might have to defend it.
The subtext is classic Marx: anyone who takes official gravitas at face value deserves the joke. Delivered in the 20th century’s long shadow of mechanized war, it also lands as a cultural flinch - a comic antidote to the era’s deadly seriousness. The line survives because it attacks not a specific war, but the evergreen fantasy that large systems can think as sharply as individuals.
The intent isn’t to claim soldiers are stupid; it’s to mock the institution’s incentive structure. Armies reward following orders, not being right. Information becomes "intelligence" only after it’s been filtered through rank, politics, and the need for clarity - and clarity is often just simplification with a uniform on. Groucho’s line targets the way power prefers certainty, even when reality is messy, and how language helps launder that preference. Call it intelligence and it feels objective; call it a guess and you might have to defend it.
The subtext is classic Marx: anyone who takes official gravitas at face value deserves the joke. Delivered in the 20th century’s long shadow of mechanized war, it also lands as a cultural flinch - a comic antidote to the era’s deadly seriousness. The line survives because it attacks not a specific war, but the evergreen fantasy that large systems can think as sharply as individuals.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Groucho
Add to List

