"My argument has always been that this is not an anti-Bush film, it's a pro-democracy film. And if Bush comes out on the wrong side of democracy, that's his problem"
About this Quote
Sayles is doing a neat rhetorical sidestep that’s also a gut-check: he refuses the easy framing of political art as partisan sniping and insists on a higher standard that makes the target feel incidental. Calling it “pro-democracy” isn’t just nicer branding; it’s a way of shifting the burden of proof. If the film’s values are democracy itself, then any politician who looks bad isn’t being attacked so much as measured - and found wanting. That’s a filmmaker’s version of “don’t blame the mirror.”
The second sentence is the knife. “If Bush comes out on the wrong side of democracy” turns an elected leader into a case study, not a villain. Sayles isn’t arguing about personality, competence, or party; he’s arguing about alignment with a civic ideal. The subtext is accusatory precisely because it pretends not to be: Bush is being positioned as someone whose choices risk placing him outside the story Americans tell about themselves.
Context matters. Sayles is an old-school American independent director, steeped in labor history, local politics, and the belief that institutions can be captured. In the Bush-era climate - Iraq, expanded executive power, the post-9/11 security state - “democracy” reads less like a Hallmark word and more like a contested terrain. Sayles’ move is strategic and moral: he’s trying to keep the film from being dismissed as liberal venting while also insisting that democracy isn’t a neutral backdrop. It’s the plot.
The second sentence is the knife. “If Bush comes out on the wrong side of democracy” turns an elected leader into a case study, not a villain. Sayles isn’t arguing about personality, competence, or party; he’s arguing about alignment with a civic ideal. The subtext is accusatory precisely because it pretends not to be: Bush is being positioned as someone whose choices risk placing him outside the story Americans tell about themselves.
Context matters. Sayles is an old-school American independent director, steeped in labor history, local politics, and the belief that institutions can be captured. In the Bush-era climate - Iraq, expanded executive power, the post-9/11 security state - “democracy” reads less like a Hallmark word and more like a contested terrain. Sayles’ move is strategic and moral: he’s trying to keep the film from being dismissed as liberal venting while also insisting that democracy isn’t a neutral backdrop. It’s the plot.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List



