"My experience of the world is that things left to themselves don't get right"
About this Quote
Huxley warns that improvement is not the natural drift of the world. Experience teaches that neglect breeds disorder: gardens revert to bramble, tools rust, institutions corrode, and even memories fade without rehearsal. The line resonates with a scientist’s eye for process. In nature, order needs energy; without effort, things fall apart. That is less a moral lament than a recognition of how systems behave.
As Darwin’s fiercest defender, Huxley knew evolution carries no promise of moral progress. Natural selection solves immediate problems of survival, not questions of justice. In his Romanes Lecture, later published as Evolution and Ethics, he drew a sharp line between the “cosmic process” of nature and the “ethical process” of civilization. Left alone, the cosmic process favors tooth and claw. To build a humane society, people must cultivate against that grain, as gardeners weed and water against the pull of wild growth. The phrase “left to themselves” rejects a comforting Victorian faith that history or markets will set everything right if we simply stand back. It pushes against Herbert Spencer’s evolutionary optimism and the era’s laissez-faire mood, arguing for education, public health, and reform as acts of deliberate resistance to decay.
The same stance explains Huxley’s devotion to rigorous scientific method. Reliable knowledge comes from disciplined observation and controlled experiment, not from letting ideas fend for themselves in the mind. The lab, like the polis, requires design, critique, and maintenance.
There is a faint echo of the second law of thermodynamics here: without input, systems tend toward disorder. But Huxley turns that insight into an ethic of stewardship. Progress is made, not inherited. It depends on vigilance, institutions that are tended, and habits of mind that are trained. The message is anti-fatalist. Do not wait for things to right themselves; they rarely do. Bring energy, judgment, and care, or be prepared for the slow, reliable triumph of neglect.
As Darwin’s fiercest defender, Huxley knew evolution carries no promise of moral progress. Natural selection solves immediate problems of survival, not questions of justice. In his Romanes Lecture, later published as Evolution and Ethics, he drew a sharp line between the “cosmic process” of nature and the “ethical process” of civilization. Left alone, the cosmic process favors tooth and claw. To build a humane society, people must cultivate against that grain, as gardeners weed and water against the pull of wild growth. The phrase “left to themselves” rejects a comforting Victorian faith that history or markets will set everything right if we simply stand back. It pushes against Herbert Spencer’s evolutionary optimism and the era’s laissez-faire mood, arguing for education, public health, and reform as acts of deliberate resistance to decay.
The same stance explains Huxley’s devotion to rigorous scientific method. Reliable knowledge comes from disciplined observation and controlled experiment, not from letting ideas fend for themselves in the mind. The lab, like the polis, requires design, critique, and maintenance.
There is a faint echo of the second law of thermodynamics here: without input, systems tend toward disorder. But Huxley turns that insight into an ethic of stewardship. Progress is made, not inherited. It depends on vigilance, institutions that are tended, and habits of mind that are trained. The message is anti-fatalist. Do not wait for things to right themselves; they rarely do. Bring energy, judgment, and care, or be prepared for the slow, reliable triumph of neglect.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work Ethic |
|---|
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List
