"Nature that framed us of four elements, warring within our breasts for regiment, doth teach us all to have aspiring minds"
About this Quote
Machiavelli smuggles ambition into biology, making it sound less like a vice than a design feature. The image is almost medical: we are “framed” from four elements, not harmoniously blended but “warring within our breasts for regiment.” Regiment is the tell. It is a political word wearing a naturalist costume. The inner life, for Machiavelli, is already a contested state, a miniature principality where competing forces jostle for command. If our guts are built for power struggles, then wanting mastery outside ourselves starts to look less like corruption and more like continuation.
The specific intent is to normalize aspiring minds as inevitable, even rational. By placing desire for dominance inside the body’s operating system, Machiavelli undercuts moralists who preach contentment as virtue and ambition as sin. He’s also offering cover to leaders: if people are constituted by conflict, politics cannot be a seminar on goodness; it is crisis management for creatures engineered to push upward.
Context matters. Writing in a Renaissance Italy of fragmented city-states, mercenary armies, and volatile patronage, Machiavelli watched fortunes rise and collapse with brutal speed. Classical and medieval ideas about the four elements (and the humors) were still cultural common sense, so he repurposes familiar “science” to argue a harder point: instability isn’t an exception, it’s the baseline.
The subtext is both bleak and bracing. Ambition isn’t merely permitted; it’s taught by nature itself. If you want peace, don’t ask humans to stop aspiring. Build institutions, strategies, and personal discipline that can harness the war inside the chest before it spills into the streets.
The specific intent is to normalize aspiring minds as inevitable, even rational. By placing desire for dominance inside the body’s operating system, Machiavelli undercuts moralists who preach contentment as virtue and ambition as sin. He’s also offering cover to leaders: if people are constituted by conflict, politics cannot be a seminar on goodness; it is crisis management for creatures engineered to push upward.
Context matters. Writing in a Renaissance Italy of fragmented city-states, mercenary armies, and volatile patronage, Machiavelli watched fortunes rise and collapse with brutal speed. Classical and medieval ideas about the four elements (and the humors) were still cultural common sense, so he repurposes familiar “science” to argue a harder point: instability isn’t an exception, it’s the baseline.
The subtext is both bleak and bracing. Ambition isn’t merely permitted; it’s taught by nature itself. If you want peace, don’t ask humans to stop aspiring. Build institutions, strategies, and personal discipline that can harness the war inside the chest before it spills into the streets.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Niccolo
Add to List









