Skip to main content

Daily Inspiration Quote by Abe Fortas

"Needless, heedless, wanton and deliberate injury of the sort inflicted by Life's picture story is not an essential instrument of responsible journalism"

About this Quote

“Needless, heedless, wanton and deliberate” is a prosecutorial drumbeat, a stacking of adjectives meant to make harm feel not just real but morally variegated: careless, lustful, intentional. Fortas writes like someone who knows that in American media culture, cruelty often arrives wearing the costume of “just reporting.” His target is Life magazine’s photo-essay style, where images don’t merely inform; they stage emotion, recruit gawkers, and turn private pain into public product.

The line’s power is in what it refuses to concede. Fortas doesn’t argue that journalism must be gentle, or that the public has no right to know. He argues something narrower and more dangerous to the press: that a category of injury is surplus. “Not an essential instrument” sounds modest, even technocratic, but it’s a legal wedge. If harm is nonessential, then it’s easier to regulate without “killing” the First Amendment. That’s the subtext: a constitutional balancing act disguised as a common-sense rebuke.

Context matters. Fortas, a Supreme Court justice associated with expansive civil liberties, is not a natural scold about the media. That makes the sentence land harder: it’s an internal critique from someone who generally values expressive freedom, yet still sees a line between exposing wrongdoing and manufacturing humiliation. He’s anticipating a world where reputational damage is scalable and permanent, insisting that responsibility isn’t just accuracy. It’s restraint, proportionality, and the willingness to leave some wounds unphotographed.

Quote Details

TopicEthics & Morality
SourceHelp us find the source
More Quotes by Abe Add to List
Fortas on Responsible Journalism and Gratuitous Harm
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

USA Flag

Abe Fortas (June 19, 1910 - April 5, 1982) was a Judge from USA.

1 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes